snowkatt: some were wel done some where arse
and in star wars case instead of fixing the by then wonky special effects it was used as an excuse to "fix"every fucking thing
darthspudius: I haven't seen a bad remaster of Trek yet. The sooner they get to Deep Space Nine the better.
But the whole thing with Star wars, I mean for the love of Spock's ghost... why can't they leave it alone haha. I'd love to see the people who did that specific CGI work on the films in an interview.
in some cases the cgi is very obviously cgi
i have tos on vhs and the remasters on dvd i kinda like the originals vhs versions better btu that sbecause the softer vhs actually masks the wonky special effects
especially the first tos remasters cgi looks a bit iffy
and no comment on what i said about the splintered transformers fandom ? ;p