Pheace: The fact that you keep repeating this just shows how little you know of this game, and I'm not going to spoiler it for those who still want to play it. 
  There is nothing to spoil. Only silence and emptiness. :)   
Fenixp: First of all, this is not true - not for DOOM which reached it sales goals and definitely not for Mad Max. 
  And they reached it sales goals? And who told you that? You saw docs with inner plans of the company, what they was hoping for?   
Fenixp: Secondly, I assume you consider games like Arcanum, Planescape: Torment or System Shock 2 some of the worst games in history. 
  They wasn't planned as AAA titles anyway and they had very big problems: Arcanum - many bugs, some of them preventing player from finishing game. Planescape: Torment - big part of the game wasn't finished and they had to cut it out. For example, romances with Anna or Fall from Grace (there are files with voiced dialogue in the game foles for romance conversations) and corresponding endings. System Shock 2 was considered boring by the many at the moment of release.   
Fenixp: Not a single mention of gameplay. 
  Sure, for example is an AI: player can jump right in front of an enemy and enemy reaction will be "Huh?" and standing there for many seconds. You can even kill someone right next to another person and they won't even notice it. Stellar gameplay! :)   
Fenixp: The repetition is usually felt by people who play on easy difficulties and never even need to swap weapons to adjust to new situations. 
  Oh, i love that, when someone understand that gameplay is mediocre at most, they start to say: the game is good only at the hardest difficulty, all other is not what it should be. So, in other words, developers optimized gameplay on the hardest and all others was put in the last seconds just to be there.  
 And to see the game at its best i should start grinding every bossfight until i manage to do it without any mistakes from my side for a 10-20 times without my keyboard going in the window.  
 I start to understand what modern players call Stellar Gameplay. :)   
Fenixp: Of course, aside from the fact that majority of people consuming dirt will tell you it wasn't a great experience, whereas majority of people playing DOOM, Mankind Divided or Metal Gear Solid V will tell you they're great fun. 
  Oh, its so good to thins that a majority is supporting your point of view. But tell me, why do you think that it's the majority opinion? Metacritic or Steam ratings? There are some ways to affect them if you have enough money: 
http://arstechnica.com/gaming/2016/09/valve-steam-cheating-review-scores-devs/  
 And what about all those videos on youtube? They are minority? But that doesn't make problems go away, even if that is true. :)   
Fenixp: As long as you actively want to dislike these games based on reports of absolute minority of players, you will. 
  Oh, you already counted all the negative reports, compared it's quantity with amount of positive reports, and now absolutely sure that "dislike these games based on reports of absolute minority of players"? Sorry, but i doubt that you counted. And if you do, did you counted it right? :)