oldwino: I just did a full re-read and have five scum leans, two nulls and two town leans. Nothing is confirmed in my mind, but I have leanings and it's time to get on with soritng scum as best as we can, vote, and then use whatever results we get, right or wrong.
In my previous six games, I usually gave read lists, often to stir things up but I can now see how that might help scum more than town, so no lists from me, not yet. And this game doesn't need any more stirred up right now.
First two lines are I made a list but I am not going to share it. Why bring it up then?
Lifthrasil: one of meda/Quad (preferably meda, since she has already used up her PR shot, if her claim is true) would also still be an acceptable lynch for me. If they are telling the truth, we get one actually confirmed townie. If they are lying, we get two confirmed scum. So this would be a good deal, unless we decide that these two are absolutely trustworthy for some reason - and that decision is difficult without Quad actually contributing. So, again, Quad please stop fuming and resume playing!
I can see your stance on the best way to figure this out for sure is kill one. However, I think some people play with more their heart then logic and that might make this hard to impossible.
RW seems rightly upset with no answers or even repsonses at all.
oldwino jumps right on RW point and adds players who are not contributing to the pool as well. But then, makes sure to mention he feels bad for his vote. (I am not liking this at all).
medamiedo: We are confirmed town; scum know we are confirmed town; they WILL kill us unless they are terrible. Basically done repeating myself here; there's zero town motivation in continuing to make this the discussion point and loads of scum motivation for it so for the love of god, start talking about reads and actually alignment indicative things, please people.
actually I think you are wrong here. I think your coming out and claiming this right now actually hurts us. It gives them more of a idea on who to go after role wise. You just took two options out of the mix of people who are after power roles.
Lifthrasil: @all:
actually I am less inclined to vote meda by now. Policy lynching one of meda/Quad to confirm the other is of course still on the table, but with meda's added explanations, her role looks a bit less ridiculous. If her first attempt didn't fail as such, but she wasn't allowed to take that attempt and drealmer said 'Oh, there was something I didn't think of. Target someone else please' ... then she actually doesn't have a mutli-shot-in-one-Day power, but her claim is reduced to a One-Shot-Day-Masonizer. Still not a normal role, but better than the 'I can use several shots in one Day' version, that it appeared to be beforehand. So for now I would prefer to lynch the one who looks scummiest by far: Gamma. But I still want Quad to pitch in, since a lot hinges on what his version of the 'masonization' actually is.
I agree with you on note voting Meda right now. There are some things that have a hint of my role. No where near major but some small pieces that blend into mine too. So I can not keep my vote on meda
unvote meda GammaEmerald: Until we actually know how this role is SUPPOSED to work.
I have a feeling we will learn more in day two.
RWarehall: How about answering a direct question...is your power specifically named Masonizer or Mason Recruiter?
I would like to hear the answer to this too.
RWarehall: Quad sure isn't helping either by being absent.
At this point I have to seriously consider the possibility that this was some sort of crazy scum ploy on Meda's part. That without day chat, Quad was going WTF and is avoiding us because he cannot come up with a good response. This gets compounded by the idea that Meda keeps crying for protection when at this point, she's at best Vanilla town that nobody seems to trust. Certainly not the "confirmed town" that scum has to target.
I can see this as I have said but where you are willing to lynch meda and not Quad. Why keep the one who is not talking and helping over the one that is if it is proven true.
I really am not a fan of meda not answering my questions to her. Its not good to pick and choose when to answer unless you are trying to hide and dont want to answer it.