GeForce 1660 Super. I made some compromise between quality and price and ended with this one.

Thsi is fake fallacy and you are simply saying, "don't kill me I am town". Mafia will target town at night no matter what so from town side it's not much difference if tehy are confirmed already or not.

That doesn't really explain it. You are saying you singled me out because you chose to single me out.


That's actually good point.

I know I am the person who doesn't know how RB resolve but I like to think I know at least some things about mafia and never heard about it before.
On the other hand it also appears to be highly unusual modifier and not one that one come across easily when creating setup. But that's speculation and can't be really judged much.
Then, it could still be same for mafia PGO you mused about.

Sigh.
Unvote GymHanson but I will most likely revote in few hours but I need to think about it first.

"Fake" fallacies are the worst.

No, I'm pretty sure true fallacies are the worst ones. Better to be a tautology than an oxymoron!

No, more like possible scum trying to get an easy mislynch. Sorry if it came off as anything else.

That's not the point...it's that if I am lynched it is very likely town will be down 2 fellow town instead of 1.

And if I were scum and a PR got taken out it's likely i'd be the next day's lynch anyways...I wouldn't be able to hide if scum.

-----------

@ZFR: Seriously. If I get taken out by mislynch and there is a NK then town is down 2 town instead of 1.

So since I consider you town, that seems like very unwise town play......unless you have good reasoning for it(that i'm not seeing), perhaps?

So the only "risk" I'm taking is a single additional person. One who is who is likely to be a distraction, a general liability and who for all I know could still be Mafia trying to make the best of a bad situation. Yes, I'm more than willing to risk it.

Nice pick...hope you have fun with it.

What I meant and was focusing on is that if I get lynched and scum do a NK, town will be down 2 town for certain(of course this is based on my claims, so take it fwiw). Whereas if town went a different route(another lynch or no lynch) town would only be down 1 town. Simple maths....1 loss is better than 2....that is what I was getting at.

You seemed scummy to me, so of course I was focusing on you in regards to that post. I have listed my leans in other posts as well, though.

----

@ZFR: That one extra person could make all the difference in helping to win the game(in terms of numbers), though.

It's only a distraction if players let it be one.....one way of dealing with a distraction is to also ignore it or set it aside, you know.

Hmm. It is fairly obscure, but I think he's already said he's been looking at the wiki for strategies. There's also the possible-day-chat-slip. If GH is maf and has day chat he might be being coached by a more experienced buddy.

In that case I don't see a link between the two situations really. One is a game where I was scum saying we should lynch the cop (who happened to be you) and one is a game where I am town and suspect someone of being mafia (who happens to be you). Given that they're completely different games with different role assignments, the only thing the two situations have in common are that we're both playing. If we keep playing more games together, there are bound to be more situations involving both of us, but they won't have any more to do with these situations than they do with each other.

You're just describing a mislynch. Statistically, most days will end with a mislynch and the NK of a townie. Some days we might get scum and some nights we might block a kill, but the situation you're describing is hardly out of the ordinary. You're basically just saying "I'm not scum" with more words.

Well exactly. But if you're on the ropes anyway you'd obviously try and take a town PR down before you go down.

This is literally the same argument you made to me above.

Again 100% agree. Hence we're not letting it be one.

You should some day ask my team mates from games where I was scum just how good I am at following coaching advice.

You're not scum? Ok then, i'll take your word for it.....o.0

In a role madness game, if I were scum, would it matter much? Especially a game with likely only 2 scum?

I like to repeat myself....a lot.

----------

@ZFR: As I said, there are other ways to deal with a distraction then by removing it.....but if you want to follow that single minded course of action then so be it.

You're essentially asking us to just clear you on faith and leave you alone to the end of the game? Well that would certainly be convenient if you were mafia.

More like put it on the back burner for a bit. I mean look at how many games where I was town and a distraction, got removed and shown to be town...iirc it was more often than I turned out to be scum.

Let me propose something: if we have an investigative role they look into me perhaps....if something happens to them I will gladly await the lynch and even throw in a vote(not the hammer) myself.

What say you?

Also what says everyone else?

Name one.

One that, assuming you're Town, doesn't rely on scum magically becoming moronic morons overnight and deciding to NK you when *literally*, NKing anyone else, including possibly going with noNK for the mindscrew, is a better option for them.

Let's say we do "put you on the back burner", we'd have to lynch you eventually. And the later in the game it happens, the more destructive it could be.

That's silly for all of the reasons I've already mentioned. If you're a mafia PGO you could easily just be trying to take a town PR down with you.

In case that's not clear, it's a no from me.