It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Microfish_1: Thanks! Okay, the claim formula reads as follows: Does this mean that
1) if two people bid "Doc", and both bid "5", the lower tiebreaker goes first, or does it mean
2) if two people bid "5", they pick after the one person who bid "6", even though all 3 bid for different roles?
#2 is correct, if more than one person bid the same number as their primary then they went after someone who bid a unique primary number.
Both

Both are correct

pick order would go:

6/1 "Bid Role A - got Role A"
5/1 "Bid Role B - got Role B"
5/2 "Bid Role B - got nothing"
Thank you, Trent.
Unfortunately, it also blew my whole theory sky-high. :(

I bid 4 and will reveal my tiebreaker later. WHO ELSE BID 4??
Yes, yogsloth is correct. I misread #1
Microfish_1: Thank you, Trent.
Unfortunately, it also blew my whole theory sky-high. :(

I bid 4 and will reveal my tiebreaker later. WHO ELSE BID 4??
It don't matter, fish

Tell me your thoughts on the current gamestate

Who are the mafia
I was hoping it went

#4-1 Bids A, gets A
#5-1 Bids B, gets B
#5-2 Bids B, gets nothing
#6-1 Bids C, gets C
Microfish_1: Thank you, Trent.
Unfortunately, it also blew my whole theory sky-high. :(

I bid 4 and will reveal my tiebreaker later. WHO ELSE BID 4??
yogsloth: It don't matter, fish

Tell me your thoughts on the current gamestate

Who are the mafia
Am I missing something. If Micro bid 4 and you bid 13 on same role.... why did you get it?

And if someone else bid for it and went 4, then... huh? who did?
Microfish_1: I was hoping it went

#4-1 Bids A, gets A
#5-1 Bids B, gets B
#5-2 Bids B, gets nothing
#6-1 Bids C, gets C
the mafia fish

who are the mafia

ZFR: Am I missing something. If Micro bid 4 and you bid 13 on same role.... why did you get it?

And if someone else bid for it and went 4, then... huh? who did?
same question
I'm not sure, and don't have time to answer atm. I was gonna call you out if example #1 (and NOT #2) was true. I need to reread, but can't for a few hours.
Booooo!

I guess we'll wait.

In the meantime, I truly have no idea what bookwyrm thinks he's looking for.

The suspense will have to kill me.
TBH, I was prepared to bury you so far that you wouldn't see daylight for a week (especially at night), Yog, but Trent blew up my theory in my face, so....
Microfish_1: TBH, I was prepared to bury you so far that you wouldn't see daylight for a week (especially at night), Yog, but Trent blew up my theory in my face, so....
Yeah, great

Okay. So now that that's not happening

Who da wolves
flubbucket: poke
Bookwyrm627: Flub? Any comments to help the undecided among us decide what to do?

.........
Yes.

yogsloth: One time I beat a man to death with his own dentures.
Bookwyrm627: But Flub still wins every now and then.
No.

JoeSapphire: ...........

I investigated Korotan night one,
.........
Nonsense.

flubbucket:
JoeSapphire: Is Yogsloth right? would you refuse to claim if pushed?

...........
Yes.

I wish there were a logical way to explain picking Korotan for a Night One Investigation.
flubbucket: I wish there were a logical way to explain picking Korotan for a Night One Investigation.
Final vote count of Day 1:

trentonlf: Prettiest Princess Award:

yogsloth (PookaMustard, Microfish)

bookwyrm (Korotan, yogsloth, JoeSapphire, blotunga)
Blotunga (ZFR, bookwyrm flub, dedo)

Closest to winning the contest with 4 votes is bookworm, & blotunga, it takes 6 votes to win the contest.

Everyone is voting

It is a pretty odd look. Joe and Korotan are on the same wagon.

Hey Joe-

Why not bookwyrm, whom you were voting? Or Blotunga, who was the counterwagon?

What's the reasoning here?