Read this post, particularly the longest paragraph, and ask yourself what is the perspective of the person who wrote this. Town or scum? Or in other words, do you read this as a townie listing all reasons why someone is no good, or a mafia goon who noticed a sitting duck and is looking for arguments to shoot it down no matter what ("if he's town, he's too inexperienced to be useful, if he's a power role, he's a liability (?), if he's third party, he has to die (!), and if he's scum, well, obviously he has to die")?

It's not a solid argument what I'm presenting here, not by a long shot, but it's something at least.

I've been thinking about that post for the better part of the day, and I'm not sure how to view it. That post in general doesn't have a town feel, especially proclaiming one as 'more lynchable' either. To be honest, I'm still confused by the wording, just because it feels, very obviously wrong.

Damnation also feels like he's playing things a bit closer to the chest then normal, but since this is the second time he's being attacked I guess it can be just, frustration.

@Bazilisek Do you think Twilight is mafia?

I'll try to write something more when I get home, but...

I can't shake the feeling that Damnation is playing kind of a 1-man game. Stressing importance of reactions vs claims, it looks like his trying to press players' buttons and then analyse their response, but refusing to share his theories/reads. I guess this can make sense, starting with treating everyone as suspects (like baz mentioned), but how does it help anyone but himself? How can the Town benefit from that?

andy433uk takes the place of Typhoon, and I worry that there will be more casualties before this game ends, strangeness seems to take its toll fast. I've got a busy day ahead of me, in many ways... I'll throw out a votecount in the late evening, now with extra extra flavor to make up for the recent lack-of.

No, I quite honestly don't. In fact, he's the strongest town read I have in the whole game. But I have been wrong before, so I'm keeping all theoretical doors open, so to speak.

ok, I'll agree there is something a bit odd about Damnations post. But i do agree with most of the points he made.

Well, now you pinpointed one of my prime suspects.
I have strange feeling from Damnation posts, I don't like his "more lynchable", attempt to lynch least experienced player and I don't like how he tried so much to diminish amount of experiences he has as he don't want to be connected with something suspicious. Yes, baz, did the same but from him I have much more positive reads so fr so I am willing to forgive him. :-)
Also his, "I know something but won't tell you but I had to tell you I know it so you can wonder what is it," is something I don't like at all.

There are other players I suspect on bigger than standard level but Damnation is my number 1 maybe 2 right now.

I read Damnation as suspect.

But then, as it's me saying that, does it make him look more town to everyone else? ;-}

Why should it as you were suspicious of him earlier. Unless you're claiming mafia :P

It was a semi serious reference to the fact that most people seem to think my lines of reasoning are flawed.
Therefore, if I think he may be Mafia....

Personally I think your lines of reasoning are similar to Nmillar's. Which makes you terrifying.

Terrifying for mafia. :P

I compare my "rabid dog" to Nmillar's "bull in a china shop".

I'm just as unrelenting, potentially just as likely to aim wrong, but nowhere near as blinkered.