^ That's... a lot of Mafia readings.
We wouldn't survive long with such setup, I think.

Heck, if he was correct, Mafia would have already won!

lol, everyone starts off as mafia in my mind.

Though Rob, Typhoon, Thiev and Nmillar are probably town as well.

Which is the best approach to the game, no doubt about that.

Violator is in the game?
Violator and Rodzaju together??
Two scums identified!!!

I am only town here? I feel intimidated.

I just got back and briefly passed out due to seeing orry write more than 5 lines on a thread page :D

Your not alone as town as im teleroths replacement hes town but doesnt half come out with some crazy talk. I think he was speculative more about the game due to how he thinks the experienced players are getting the good roles.

15 does bring an interesting point of if the roles have been cherry picked who would be the best shoes to fill them.

Looking at the flavor which GQ said was key she had 2 good friends in Jamie Heath and Luke Testa does that implicate that they are both town?

The latter piece of text
"Jack! Oh thank god -- She's dead... Wrapped in plastic."

I did watch Twin Peaks as a kid but was to young to work out what was going on.... Though from doing a bit of reading does match what I think is going/going to happen. Speculation aside im going to discuss the players after this. It does help in the 3 ways to hell name for me anyway. Its appears to be similar but hell I may be completely wrong.

This ive picked up through reading player comments.

Thiev:Seems suspect hes using his inexperience to implicate that he is town, Maybe hes playing the card to divert the odds that he is mafia, I would be very surprised if the 3 most experienced players were ALL mafia. They could have easily have thrown you in to be mentored <----------- FOS

Pazzer:Post 284 is Probably the most paranoid list of opinions ive ever seen in a mafia game, I do also find you omit vitek as being the only person you are confident is town, a little bit suspect. Coupled with the earlier idea of a mass claim I think your fishing for roles.

If its anything to do with Twin Peaks and its plot what I think it is I can see why somebody experienced would be needed as it would be a difficult role to partake

That being said I find it very suspect the way nmillar jumped on damnation regarding his name and searching for a claim, maybe he's searching for a suitable "host"

Pre-Post Edit:I was going to vote nmillar but Actually I changed my mind thiev sticks out like a sore thumb and it would feel like persecution if i vote for him again. Maybe its his restriction to sound like the new kid in town but im not buying it.

Vote Thiev

As I said prior: those who know what the opening is an homage to will be at a distinct disadvantage.

Well, for the time being I'm again going to Unvote as I'll let Violator make his own mistakes instead of suffer for not being able to mind read.

I'm going to take a bit and reread I think expect my vote going somewhere later.

Hi, I am going away for few days and am not sure if I'll be able to reach internet until Monday evening so have a patience with me, please.

Indeed - I'd noticed Orryyrro was posting more, but an attack on a person for a change in activity which would usually be considered "more town" would be considered churlish at best. As for his trying to get a claim early on? That sounds like my logic to vote against him in game #5, and that turned out to be horribly wrong. I think it might be just how he plays.

That said, I haven't seen a game where he's turned out to be on the Mafia side in the end, so I could be wrong - if one of the completed games did involve this, do tell which one it is. Assuming that whoever knows actually thinks this sort of train of thought is helpful, of course - I do sometimes need reminded that I've gone off the rails. :P

Righto, sorry I've been absent these last two days, but I finished my bachelor thursday and used my entire friday on cleaning up and hanging out with friends. I'm going to take a reread of the entire thread to see if I can find any additional dirt (I'm sure I left some behind in previous posts :p) but stay tuned for more crazy theories and retarded reasoning!

Well, I didn't get a chance to post yesterday, but yes I am posting more. It has a rather lot to do with being done exams. I still like short posts in most cases though. :P

It's this Directly lied to (Ghosts actually said "Outright lied to", but it amounts to the same thing) that's got me worried.
It suggests that there is potential for lack of clarity about a players role.
It also gives Ghost wiggle room to evolve roles as the game progresses.

Is this to allow her to replace roles that she considers vital, just in case they get killed early?
Or something entirely more sinister....

Just realised that I've been lurking worse than Orryyrro. Time to rectify that!

The ones that stand out the most to me at the moment are Pazzer and Thiev.
It seems a bit weird that he's sure that Vitek's town this early on.

Thiev's "I'm no harm to town" thing is somewhat suspect but it could just be bad choice of words.

I'd say.
I thought that staying completely out of mini-game will be bad. In restrospection, I should make some joking statement, as others did.

Apparently I chose the worst possibilty, that made Town wary of me and gave others convenient excuse to flag me as the most suspicious.
Oh well, live and learn. Or just learn.