O-kee do-kee....new questions(if I may): What do you think specifically of Catte not replying to my vote(even if it is an RVS vote) on them at all?
I am wondering if it could also be Catte is distracted a bit IRL or online in general....that could also be a viable possibility. What do you think?
Okay, this is 3+ pages of Calibri 11 with no spacing between lines, and probably won't all fit on one poste. I should reread it for consistencies sake, and to see if I need to add anything to anything, but I'm tired and IRL is stressful, so meh.
Why not comic sans or webdings? Then it might at least be more fun to type it out. ;) (Also sorry to hear you're stressed out IRL)
I think it unusual for Catte to not respond at all. He did mention being in a bad mood the one day (i think due to IRL?) and setting the game aside, but there have been several days since then. @catte
please comment about this matter. Are you scum? this line is not a vote.
Webdings is notoriously hard to read and I don't know if GOG could interpret it.
The forum ate my post so i'm typing this in word. hopefully i'll remmember it all.
Which "fluff post" of yours
do you think I'm talking about here?
Why do you think I'm talking about you at all? Because I referenced Catte's fluff post
, which was the trigger for me "manufacturing an argument", which I thought was what we were talking about...
if you check Catte's fluff post, you notice that he was referring to me, so i didn't know which fluff post you meant. Sorry, my brain was / is tired. We were talking about the Catte post and I dropped the ball.
This is a nice, subtle bit of LAMISTing. I'm glad no one else noticed it so that I could. (Or maybe it means I need to reread the concept to see what it is :/ ) Is it customary that you are
townread? Have you ever been full scum? Were you townread in the games where you were anti-town?
Yes. Yes "scum" (anti-town), No "mafia" (answered previously in #157
). Yes. Game #67, post #84
might be a useful reference, where I posted a similar thing, and was town. (Which of course doesn't prove that I'm town now, but does invalidate the LAMIST argument in my eyes.) You might also notice you having read that post before, as evidenced by you responding in post #85. In general, I'd advice you to reread our interactions on D1 of #67, and compare.
Thank you for your answers. Sorry for the bother of asking what you'd already answered.
The reason I saw it as LAMIST was that it has been drilled into my head that saying "i've always been town, so i am now" is bad, and even "i expect everyone to think I am" is also...questionable, because if the logic that says your previous roles say nothing about your current one, than the same should apply to everyone's perception of everyone else.
Maybe I was trying too hard to find something to pick apart, but I'd almost rather try too hard than not try at all. I honestly thought I had something for a moment. :-(
i shall reread 67 D1, I hope.
I did not read it as such. If I had, I wouldn't have brought it up as you being positive about me, to ask what changed.
okay, i'd wanted to make that point in case there was misunderestanding by you or anyone as to what i meant.
You are aware that this is a complete logical fallacy, right? The sky is blue. Therefore, everything that's blue is the sky.
I applaud you being aware of your biases, and trying to counter them, but you're overcompensating tremendously. (The question for me is, are you doing so because you're a misguided townie, or because you're scum trying to get rid off me.)
You accused Joe early on, and have given a narrative that I find somewhat compelling--this is where it gets tricky for me. If he flips town (contrary to what I suspect), you are most likely scum who backed off when they saw a better target
Where did I "back off"?
Joe was my first - and so far only - real lov^H^H^Hvote. (I don't think dedo saw that, did he?)
Does this answer your question? I feel that i have forgotten something important...
You didn't answer this question of mine:
(Still defying the odds, eh?)
And I notice the contrast with #67
You are right, I didn't check the vote count and thought you had voted for another after Joe Maybe I'm being snookered by you, in which case i tip my hat to you.
Ah. I see, i think, how it is a fallacy? But as there is
some historical basis for my theory, I will continue to keep it in mind, while admitting that volume of talking does not equal scumminess of the talker.
I'll try and overcompensate less. I know that I have previously been accused of being too wary of being pocketed and thus not always listening to reason (I think it was mentioned in the Lift vs. Joppo game?), but I fear that the one time I let my gaurd down, some nasty scummy person will swoop right in, pick me up, and drop me in his/her pocket where I'll be stuck for the rest of the game, maybe not even struggling futilely to get out. However, thank you for pointing this flaw out; i'll work on it. If you could provide further details of how I am overcompensating, it would be useful. (If i became convinced that you were town, i'd be doing everything i could to not attic you.)
I saw your question, but as my answer hasn't changed, I wasn't sure if it was worthy of a response for the same reasons I enumerated then.
How do I dare answer? :D if I make a big production out of it, I will be shot down [again], which accomplishes nothing. However, the most foolish of scum would still answer, "yes!" to such a question. They might even answer, "Yes, a thousand times, YES!" So, I won't do that,
but just tell you that I am, indeed, boringly, town.
At least this doesn't appear like a loaded question. blobsweat.jpg
However, especially right now, boring is good. if only IRL was stress-free, I'd be set. (if that is too wordy for your tastes, i state that I'm a honourable citizen of the town, if a very tired one atm.)
PS: Gogtrial is not my preffered vote. I said I would prefer gogtrial over NL. I'd almost prefer anyone but Micro to NL. I'm sticking to Joe for now. I was commenting in that instance on how a lot of people seem to be questioning gogtrial, more so than others. Maybe Catte is a better choice for NL, as GH seems to try to imply. Maybe I should switch from my focus on gogtrial to catte. I don't know. Atanyrate it is not and never was a "gogtrial is my 1st choice" thing.
@gogtrial, see my post 90, where i laid out reasons as to why i believe trent could be scum and reasons for the reverse.. I have a hard time reading him. i could argue that he was or wasn't scum, and idk which argument i'd believe. rereading my comments, it appears that i never actually asked if Trent would ever support a fellow scummate if they had a teeny bit of suspicion on them. He isn't afraid to bus, I know, but idk if he saw someone wrongly attacking --especially if they were attacking a teammate, if he'd support that teammate, if not to the hilt.
My full quote is
if gogtrail is scum, I can see how trent could be too, but I don't know if he'd support his fellow scum or avoid doing so.
and until that is answered, I hypothesize what i said above but still wonder.
As to how many times? so far 57t 59t 60t 61t 64t 65t 67(M) and i didn't analyze trent post-game to see how he played, so i don't know.
PPS: i've been focussing on you because you have replied to me more than others and given me things to talk about, which is more than many have done -- other than GH, and I really cannot tell GH's alignment on D1.
GN all for reals this time