Amazingly ambitious game with a few frustrations. I almost quit playing it on more than one occasion. I'm glad I didn't.
The visuals and details are quite amazing for a 2 year old game. Especially the actors in the game (not only voices, but they modeled all the actors after the talent). Seeing Greg Grunberg, John Noble, Andrew Connolly and 60+ other notable actors in game was quite impressive from a technical perspective... and hence, the voice acting was pretty good ;)
i love the clue finding and interrogating mechanics... sadly, these were quite flawed. More sadly, this isn't just my opinion as you have the ability to see how the community answers and every time I checked choices were split around the 40% mark between 2 choices. The graphics were clearly good enough that human emotion can help you see where the logic is... but too many places split the logic between 2 answers forcing you into a developer mind reading mini-game... which is not fun for me.
To anyone that hasn't played this game, I'd suggest this short video for what it has in store: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2zhtGEA9TyA