GamezRanker: You seem to forget one thing: most of my crumbs were written/placed BEFORE the reboot Back then(as I said earlier in the game, maybe even a few times) I didn't know so many were psychoanalysts & figured I had lucked out with a good role, so I decided to crumb it....and subtly to avoid scum possibly seeing it and thinking of making me the NK(due to it being an investigative role).
=-=-=-=-=-=
(To all, please read!) =-=-=-=-=-=
We now know the following with certainty.....Yogs was one of the scum post reboot, and Lift was one pre reboot(we dunno about his status now, obviously).
So, given the above(and the likelihood this is a 2 scum game), it seems(key word) Micro is suggesting the following: that I was/am scum pre and post reboot(as I started crumbing my role back then), and also chose to derpily out my own scum mate pre-reboot(Post 21 iirc) while Lift and the OP were trying to hide what Lift had posted originally in Post 20(to avoid a need for a reboot).
And that then in my "cleverness" as scum, I then: LOUDLY hammered a town on D1, helped to hammer Yogs on D2(while planning to then run the scum game alone afterwards), and then very visibly hammered another possible town on D3.
Do any of you think that makes a lick of sense, or that i'd be capable of pulling all that off if it did?
I... never thought about your alignment in game 1. it literally has 0 meaning to me, because as far as we know,
every single alignment of every single player was shuffled or rerolled between games 1 & 2. ergo, your crumbs before game 2 means nothing for your current alignment. The same reason you were subtle (if town) are the same reason I did not speak up D2.
So, strike my thought that you crumbed on Game 0. That actually
weakens your claim of "look at me, I'm town because i crumbed" that you have used to attack Dogmaus and defend that.
Also, i know of at least one person who talked about breadcrumbing multiple roles "just in case".
So, what i am suggesting is that you had crumbs. Game 2 (74.5) started. You might now be scum. As scum, you saw "my role hasn't changed, just my alignment. Isn't it grand I crumbed it? now i can claim that role!
Your "derpily out a scummate Game 74.0" is meaningless because Lift was scum and found his scummate. In game 74.0 you were, i assume, town.
Your game 74.5 has nothing to do with game 74.0 except helping to figure out that everyone was psychoanalyst. IOW, all that really changed was modifiers and alignments. Your crumbs are (let me say it again as i recall them) meaningless because they equally apply to scum GR & town GR--both town or scum GR is a psychoanalyst.
D1 you LOUDLY hammered town, defended by the fact that you had a grand, accidental-insofar-as-it-related-to-your-current-role breadcrumb.
I am
ONLY claiming you might be scum post-reboot (74.5). IIRC, Lift outed Pooka in game 74.0? Anyway, that is what i picked up.
What I'm stating is that
it is possible that your very D1 loudness confirmed you as town, your D2 scum-vote helped, and it all could have been based off of an accidental breadcrumb that
met both your old and new role, but which was prepared by town!GR and is being exploited by scum!GR. I honestly did not recall that Breadcrumbs were from 74.0, thanks for pointing that out.
Lifthrasil: Damn. GOG ate another post. Annoying.
Short reconstruction of the post:
what's with the long Twilight in this game?
@Joe: you there? @Micro: small correction. In Game 1 I had a N0 result, but not really an action. I was just told by the mod that I had investigated Pooka and was told what result I got. I didn't have a choice whom to investigate.
I see, thank you for that correction. That is useful information that we (town) can benefit from.
@GR I am
hopeful you are town. The same goes for Pooka & Lift.
My natural inclination is that
If Catte was town, than:
Lift or Pooka is scum
Pooka, because he so ably defended me, and Lift because he is such an effective arguer off of slim possibilities that Yogs is likely to seize (including WIFOM black-balling me with his lunch)
HOWEVER, I wanted the odd-ball possibility out there to a) see what you would say b) provide bragging rights for post game c) get people to think and either see veracity or foolishness in what i wrote.
I
hope we got scum.
If not, and if you are town, i apologize and I'm sure scum are laughing at and thank me >:(
Well, hopefully this has been entertaining to the folks in observer chat, I know it has been for me!