Good catch!
Yeah, I had no idea and they kept flip-flopping around (moving up or down one, but sorta generally in that order. in general, that order was about right before i reread. Anyway, where is
your reads list, in order?

@everyone: please provide your reads list before Night Falls

hmm, interesting.

Query that sprang to mind: what are the "chances" of scum Psychoanalysts? As in, is that an anti-scum role, or can scum profit from it?

I say we lunch from Lift, Book, or others if Dogmaus flips town.

@Dogmaus, of course, even though I voted you, i have no animosity, I just felt at the time that you were scum. If you are town, I'm sorry.

Asking honestly: how does that even begin to make the first bit of sense?

Simply put, unless Joe filled the game with psychoanalysts for giggles and guffaws(which I find highly unlikely), it's not very likely there's more than one such role on the same team.

Which is why I suggested lynching me and Catte in ANY ORDER* as a possible win strategy.
(*should some choose to still not trust me to be town after today's hammer & it's results)

That nervous laughter there, player Dogmaus? ;)

I have asked JS in chat. JS said this game is threathening roles against non-threathening roles. Technically speaking there is no scum. This is Bizarro Mafia. This is what I have understood and I apologize if my understanding is wrong. It's the second Mafia game I'm in and it's WEIRD.
No no no animosity with anyone at all, I'm having a great time with you all and I can't wait to see how it goes. I'll be lurking and facepalming and hoping Town wins, but this was a really bad start.

ZFR was maybe afterall just misguided town, he and Lift drove me so crazy that it was hard for me to do anything else than answering to their posts agaist me from page one.
When I flip town you have to options:
think there is only one psychoanalist and lynch GR
think this game is so weird that anything can be...I wonder if there is even a third party that can win with unknown conditions at this point - we excluded that because it was threathening vs unthreathening.
I wish I could help you more.
Have fun everybody! ZFR you too I hope you can enjoy the game even without me to be beaten up around all the time!

I have one suspect(besides the now hammered Dogmaus) at the top of my list atm......and that would be Catte, for their Post 304, which seems to be a claim to the same role I have.
(I don't think Joe would put two same roles on the same team, and as such I think Catte is likely the second scum)

Well Joe did say/infer, iirc, that any role can be on either team.

Also I think even scum could profit from such a role(if they have one)......i.e. they might be able to use it to try and figure out who to NK/who to push other players to lunch first on future "days".

And if they flip scum as I suspect they will? What then?

=-=-=-=-=

Also to all, forgot one more crumb from the list in Post 314: MY AVATAR
It is from the 1999 film House on Haunted Hill, which fits my role perfectly, and is partly why I kept it and didn't change it for this game.

=-=-=-=-=

the teams are threathening roles against unthreathening roles. How are psychoanalist threathening? Sorry I can't see any internal logic and coherence in your post. You just lynched town lol. So you either are scum if there is only one psychologist or yes, JS put more than one, and they can't be different teams the way I understand this game.

But to be on the safe side, you should be lynched on D2 if you make it through the night.

But then there is a scum team.....i.e. the threatening roles.

But I thought you said there was no scum team(and thus by extension no town team)? ;)

In that example, why me and not Catte(who claimed the same thing, more or less, in post 304)?

Of course, that said, I don't mind being the lynch for D2 if Catte is the lynch for D3.

That's partly why I think it's more likely that your claim(and Catte's possible claim in post 304) are made up.

Gonna keep this up until the reveal, eh?

Both of those make no sense.

If I was scum, why would I "put myself in the bullseye" by hammering a player in the manner that I did? I'd more or less be guaranteeing myself to be the D2 lynch.

And Joe filling a game's town side with psychoanalysts? No, just no.....don't make me laugh any more than I already am, plz....my sides cannot take it. ;)

My guess? I probably won't survive to D2. Why do I think that? Simple: if I analyze another town, they can verify my town status the second I post their qualifiers on D2.

town are non threathening roles, scum threathening roles.
sorry I fail to understand your logic, I'm being honest.

we had a all-scum game here once; we could have an all town game, where the first person to realize this was the winner.

Thanks for the suggestions, btw I just had a good idea(thanks in part to my reading/replying to Dogmaus): since I more or less suspect Catte to the the second scum, I won't analyze them for N1....I will analyze(picked randomly) one of either you, Yog, or Bookwyrm. The one I analyze will likely be town, and as such can then verify if what I say is correct.

If I end up being the NK and Dogmaus flips scum(as I highly suspect they will), look into voting/lynching Catte next.

Catte needs to give a good explanation so they'd better start making one or I see them in trouble. But GR, you are too sure you got scum. I understand you seem to be excited because "finally" you got scum, but if you are town start to think about what you are going to do after I flip psychoanalist.

As per rule 11(op post) I don't think that's the case this time.....it clearly shows there are two teams.
That said, there may be some surprises hidden in the game by our wonderful game mod Joe.....who knows. p.0 :\

(bump needed)

bump

Thx
===

That's because I likely did....well, unless Joe is being ultra silly and put in like a bajillion psychoanalysts.

First thing on D2: yell at.....erm compliment Joe for a bit for such a "wonderful" game decision.

That said, I don't think i'll be needing to do that. ;)

https://c.tenor.com/uKjKZFAvCoMAAAAS/laughing-laugh.gif
trust me town start now to understand what is going on with me psychoanalist and how you are gonna go though this without decimating your own ranks.

Again, I don't think that will be a problem. ;)

I think my plan is solid: vote for both me and Catte(any order, but I prefer Catte go first for obv. reasons) on D2 and D3. That should(assuming the likelihood of you being scum) win us the game.