RWarehall: [...] you decided which WAGON you liked best to join (your words). And now Day 2 you posted how you really didn't like either of them, so "Don't blame me, not my fault". [...]
As I've questioned him about this, I'm pretty sure he didn't say anything along the lines of your second sentence. If he did and I missed it, please point to it. Otherwise you're just pulling this out of your rear end, and I'm not sure if it's in the heat of the moment, and that alone.
RWarehall: [...] I thought it was a bad idea leaving anyone at L-1 overnight. It leaves it too open for scum to roll in and mislynch him if I was wrong.[...]
There's no way to check this now, but were you here when cristigale made her decision and voted yogsloth?
RWarehall: When I went to bed, I left the idea out there that it might be a better idea to no-lynch than to lynch Dess. [...]
I'm fully behind being reluctant to lynch the claimed PR, but Dessimu wasn't the only lynch candidate, was he? What happened to "Lynch is better than No-Lynch" D1?
RWarehall: [...] You talk of how you switched to Dess as the better "wagon" of the two just
to help focus for town. [...]
[emphasis added]
Are you referring to
his post where he switched his vote? If you are, that's not how I read it. And skimming through his ISO doesn't reveal anything either. So, did he say it, or are you reading it in something he said?
Bookwyrm627: [...] Liar. I voted Dessimu to avoid "well, its end of day and Yog is the only one with a wagon. Guess we have to kill him." My previous vote (as the only person voting Lift) was going nowhere.
That's actually not quite accurate, as you can see from your
own Vote Record - the post #198 Vote Count says:
yogsloth @ L-3 - RWarehall, Lifthrasil, JMich, Dessimu
Dessimu @ L-4 - Sage103082, trentonlf, yogsloth
Lifthrasil @ L-5 - Bookwyrm627, medamiedo
Or if you want the votes in the order they were cast:
yogsloth @ L-3 - Lifthrasil, JMich, RWarehall, Dessimu
Dessimu @ L-4 - Sage103082, yogsloth, trentonlf
Lifthrasil @ L-5 - medamiedo, Bookwyrm627
So, you're both liars.
You two are starting to give me a headache again. I was thinking of dropping you two for a while, but I see you replied to me, and I see something that I don't like in your post.
Bookwyrm627: Here is my point of reference for that statement. She is starting to see RW as town, and it is near the end of D1. [...]
Do you really read that as a genuine town-read of RWarehall? I take that as her being annoyed that her, at the time, top scum-read said something towny beyond the obvious/easy 'town' statements. If she started seeing RWarehall as town at that point, why did she put him back into her scum-reads for most of D2?
It'd be good if she clarified that, but I don't see that happening before D2's end with her sparse appearances lately.
Bookwyrm627: [...] I didn't say they'd prefer a No Lynch over a mislynch; check the parenthesis at the end there. I said that [url=https://www.gog.com/forum/general/forum_mafia_47_it_tastes_like_chicken_you_wont_believe_its_flavorless/post293 ]it has already been pointed out[/url] in this game that Scum would be happy with a No Lynch. RW's failure to take a stance on who should or should not be lynched in that last time period stands out to me as him not caring overly much about which way the lynch goes.[...]
OK, clearer now. One more question, to make absolutely sure I follow you. Aft the time he unvoted, there were a total of three of us not voting (cristigale, me and him). Dessimu was at L-2, and yogsloth at L-3. He couldn't be sure that a lynch would go through (i.e. others coming on and voting in a manner that secures a lynch), could he? So, you're saying that if a lynch went through that it'd be the optimal result for scum, but if it failed, they'd also be happy with it. Is that it? And that makes him scum, yes?
Where do you have trentonlf? Town, leaning town, neutral?
Bookwyrm627: [...] It is phrased from the perspective of a town RW seeing Flub's flip. He seems pretty certain that Flub is scum, and my question is what changes in his views if Flub actually flips town instead.[...]
I definitely didn't read that this way.
Bookwyrm627: [...] JMich has elected to remain as unreadable as possible. He might be town, but he might just as easily be scum. I can't tell and he doesn't seem inclined to help decipher his alignment, so
I'm content with making sure he isn't scum. [...]
[emphasis added]
Seriously? You're willing to lynch JMich Today just to make sure he's not scum, when he could be town, and you can't tell either way? Not because he's next on your scum list after your two top suspects, not even because you find him scummy enough? Do I need to remind you that we could find ourselves in a very bad place Tomorrow? There's no guarantee we lynch scum Today, but I don't think that "finding out someone's alignment for sure because we can't read them" is a good enough reason to pick said someone.
Please tell me that I misunderstood something in what you said, because if I haven't, I don't like this one bit.
Bookwyrm627: [...] I've seen some things in her posting that concern me. [...]
Is it that hard to be specific?