phaolo: I liked those batman cartoons, but I was only talking about the 80's.
Woops about gargoyles, the style was similar.
see ?
other cartoons started to ape batman tas's animation style barely a year later
it made a huge impact on cartoons
the 80's were less kind to batman cartoons though the burton movies especially the 89 movie TAs went in to production before returns had an equally huge ( and obvious ) influence on TAS
AFnord: No, the Transformers franchise contains a lot of garbage, but the G1 comics were actually really good for what they were (I don't have a lot of experience with later comics, so I don't dare making any blanket statements, but what I've read from later comics have all been pretty good). They started a bit shakey, but once the writers were given more freedom, it actually presented some really good storylines. The comics felt like they were actually mostly written by people who cared about what they were writing.
And yes, I used to watch the cartoons as a kid, nostalgia can't save them (nostalgia did even worse when it came to saving He-man, dear lord that was bad). That's not to say that everything were bad in the 80's TF cartoons, they had their moments, but overall they were not worth watching.
That one really surprised me when I re-watched a few episodes. While I'm obviously too old for them, they were still quite good.
i do have experience with the G1 comics
and i can make blanket statements
and actually the first 12 or so US tf comics started of storngly if a bit stilted and it lead in to a 12 part storyline that is still one fo the best
where the decepticons effectivley won
optimus prime was reduced to a head
the autobots were dead
megatron was dethroned by shockwave
and there was only 1 autobot left ( ratchet )
the whole status quo was onyl just introduced and was already uprooted
its only after those issues where bob budiasky was starting to falter
he was the main architect of the transformers franchise
hasbro required him to come up with names and bio's and tech specs to form the backbone fiction of their transformers
but they also tossed quite a lot of toys each month at him which he had to introduce in the comics
and that made it hard for him to keep a narration going
most of the time he didnt even try
and after 2 years he already showed signs of burnout but they ( marvel and hasbro ) wouldnt let him go untill 1988 and issue 53 of the american series
in between issues 12 and 53 budiansky had occasional flashes of brilliance ( issues 25 26 the headmasters mini series )
but on the whole his output started to falter when it was bad it was really really bad
the tf US comics you probably read were the later issues written by simon furman budiansky's replacement ( budiansky recommended furman himself )
who was the tf UK series writer and already quite familar with transformers ( and now 25 years later he is still writing tf fiction and finished his run on marvel us with issue 100 but thats for another time )
furman tended not to talk down to his audiance and treat transformers as a space opera
transformers UK is the comic series most people refer to when they say that the G1 comic was good
and thats because it was a weekly series and the main comic was 11 pages at that so half a us comic
half of the 332 issues of the comics were reprints of the main US series
but that still leaves more then 160 issues with home grown material which are woven in and out of the Us stories and form a completer seperate counter narrative with characters that arent even seen in the Us material
and these two narratives rarely if ever clash amazingly enough
when they do however its because furman messed up ( two megatrons ...dont ask ) but on the whole tf UK still holds together quite well