Bookwyrm627, agentcarr16 are my scum choices.

Not 100% sure where you got that I'm against a claim. o_0

Lol, nope. I'm not looking for that, atm. She's just a nice girl.

I'd say have Bookwyrm go next.



Sorry if I seem like I'm lurking, I post as often as I can. I'm usually on my phone, which is why I make short replies and don't touch on everything that's come up.


My reads would be:

Lifthrasil, Brasas leaning Town.
flubbucket, Bookwyrm627 leaning Scum.

Hence I want Bookwyrm to claim next.

Mea culpa. I actually remember your math.

I apologize. I somehow got the impression there were 3 for and 2 against and somehow you just went into that brainspace I guess.

Yaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaawn.

Well then.

Vote Flub.

I am the cop, and the second scum has to be Agent or Brasas.

"Two, four, six eight, I have more face palm than you can take!"

Yeah, flubbucket is the other one against a claim.


... And Bookwyrm's claimed cop. Fun. The showdown begins.

I love the smell of paranoia in the morning. Too bad it comes from myself...

So, will the third wheel claim next, by which I mean the real cop?
If not my mind wil be blown that one of those two is actually town.


@Wyrm, so I see you're claiming to have cleared Lift. Why him?

Also please analyze the three pairs you are banking on:
1 > Flub - me
2 > Flub - Agent
3 > Agent - me

@Flub, dear lord, your pic should be in the dictionary by the Laconic entry.

So, you investigated me or Lift? Who and why?

Pair analysis... well... at least comment on the possibilites will ya?

Interesting. You are excluding me. Does that mean you investigated me? Or is it my charming personality? And if you do exclude me, why then did you ask flubbucket about voting for me?

In any case, we have our first conflict! Yay! One of these two has to be scum. Or both of them, if there is another 'true' cop around. Is there someone else who wants to claim cop? If so, please do so now!

To both flubb and Bookwyrm: what did you do tonight and what was the result?

You were not one of my choices.

So solly.

I let a little giggle out at the thought of a third cop claim. XD

I chose between Lifthrasil and Dessimu.

I, unfortunately, chose Dessimu. I say unfortunately because of the obvious.

I realize this is WIFOMy to the extreme, but it's true.

Yuck.

Yes. Unfortunate choice in retrospect, if it is true. Care to share why you chose Dessimu?


To all: about the claiming situation. I know that I was the one who suggested a Mass Claim, but I suggest we stop the claiming here. We have the conflict we need. One of the two claimants is scum, the other one will be killed tonight by scum (if we lynch correctly), being unprotectable. There is no need at the moment to reveal the doctor too.

About flubb and Bookwyrm: I'm a bit bummed that the two players I found scummiest are now in such a conflict. That means one of them is (most likely, excluding the unlikely 'both scum claim cop' scenario) not scum. Unfortunately this claim would totally make sense for both of them, no matter whether they are individually scum or town.

Scenario 1: flubb is scum: He was forced to go first and false-claiming cop would be the ideal choice for scum-flubb. He knew, he would get into conflict anyhow and by choosing cop, he forced the real cop to reveal himself (foreseeing that the mass claim might be interrupted after the first conflict).

Scenario 2: flubb is town, which means he claimed truthfully. In that case it would totally make sense for one of the scum team to jump in and counter claim. Flubb is one of the most suspicious players, on the 'probably scum' list of most players here. So going into conflict with him is more promising for scum than with any other player.


Bummer. I'll wait for Bookwyrm's statement on who he investigated before considering who to vote for.

Agreed.

No need for more claims.

I am fine with my imminent demise next Night Phase. However, Bookwyrm627 must be lynched.

I will not change my vote.

I want to see an explicit disclaimer by the rest that you are not claiming cop. We don't need to claim, just to disclaim. Because a third cop claim clears the remaining two as town 100%.

Which puts us in a much better place for D3. Of course, I assume one of those two will be night killed, but the other will have at least 50/50 chances to lynch scum for the town win. (to be clear, there would be two cops each claiming they investigated the other as scum). Otherwise there is a non null chance that the other two mislynch him for the scum win.

If there is no third cop claim I'm going to have a monster headache trying to decide which of these two is bluffing, and which of you or agent is the deep scum.

I'm also quite certain there is scum on my wagon.