IF Joe is telling the truth, the only positive about letting him live is he has to do something JOAT-y tonight if he is telling the truth, and is immediate no holds barred lunch Tomorrow.
Thank you, Joe. I appreciate your response, even though I suspect i will have to wait until post game to maybe get all of your reasoning. Also, outstanding AtE, especially the "SOWWY" and the "Oh, go on" bit at the end. Kudos to you on that. As described, it does seem like a role you would really really enjoy, and you've played it to the fullest.
However, the altrenate nights thing is worrisome. Because it could be alternate-nights-until-N5-at-which-point-it-is-fulltime.
We are at 7 players. If Joe is lying
, and does have a negative action, we lose two players, making it mislunch=lose. otoh, 4:1 is much nicer as there are two mislunches possible.
Frankly, I don't totally trust Joe to be pro-town.
...although he pretended all Day to suspect me of being scum
. He intentionally targeted Town in a way that would strengthen scum's position...
WIFOM, especially after reading a post which some might call very towny (even LAMIST?) begs the question "did he "pretend all day to suspect" because he knows
you are scum?"
However, I agree with you and Pooka. You two cannot both be scum, so one of you is town. Again, 4:1 is better than 5:2.
I haven't trusted Lift since at least last Night upon seeing Trent's flip. if I had voted for lift, and lift was the party, would Joe still have gone after Carradice?
Also to consider: Is Joe last ditch sacrificing to protect a teammate with a better role?
Still think Lift to be scum, and if not Lift, one of Caesar/Pooka/Joppo. (<<<<<Lookit how I named the entire unconfirmed playerbase right there! That was a Grade-A piece of deduction right there...yeah, i'm done now, you can stop smirking already! Yes, YOU!)
Policy says you don't let self-admitted scum continue to play the game, as seen earlier with Yogs, no matter how nice their puppy-dog eyes are! Note that if Joe is scum, Pooka & Joppo cannot both be on a scumteam, essentially confirming one of them.
Miller is Policy, Joe defends Joppo, Pooka could be GF and merely claiming Miller for an easy hiding before knowing there were no docs left, Caesar looks town and scum at times*, so no judgment there on my part, Lift is unknown.
*Wondering if 1384 is deduction or Caesar speaking what he knows to be truth from ZFR's messages to scum.
Yogs even self-voted to protect...who?
I can't do it, guys. He's got that puppy-dog look in his eyes!
Then tell us who
you would vote for?! Please.
================ vote the hero of our most recent musical, Cap'n Joe! I want Caesar and Joppo to speak before the hammer