I dunno. What level of audacity is required to claim compulsive vig with investigative elements?

(Translation: I'm not buying any sort of defense from you along the lines of "I wouldn't be audacious enough!")

For the record, I didn't say this. That was Scene, in post 801.

I hate it, especially when we're already running short on blahblahblah time.

Just one more thing.


It was the Ordinariest Ordinary game. The events that Dedo and I keep referencing occurred on Day 3.

I'd love to hear your memory on it, though, Dedo.

There's dedo and me. Who else? My read is based on bookwyrm's End Of Day2 and dedo saying that he thinks Bookwyrm's town.

Is it just sentiment? If you're allowing me to town-read you because of our intense history then tell me now. Don't let me look foolish!

Scene's logic leading him to erroneous conclusions is character trait he displays in the admin-thread and sign-up threads too. His logic isn't necessarily correct, but the conclusions that he drew came from a town-mindset. Remind me and when I have more time I'll check back and find what I'm referring to. I think it was around the beginning of Day 2.

I guess you mean Dedo, rather than blot? I don't know why I trust dedo for no reason, and I'm certainly open to that trust getting challenged. But yeah. I think he'd be reacting to me differently if he were mafia.

You read a bit more like familiar Microfish here. Are you trying harder? Am I paying more attention?

Damn if that don't make me want to unvote microfish.

But then who DO I vote? Trent or flub?

@Flub - should I vote Trent?


Also I just got microfish's joke about gogtrial asking for a sub for RL and not for the mafia game. Very good.


Usually I hate when people express "You've convinced me, if you are mafia I'd be happy to lose to this exceptional skill". but I'd happily play a game where I try to work out whether Dedo is a murderer and he compliments me relentlessly before stabbing me in the face.

Please understand, I'm not trying to defend myself. I'm trying to evoke critical thinking.

I don't know.

I can't decide if he's the lone frustrated scum or myopic town.

Why? If you think I’m scum then vote me, if you don’t then move on as we are short on time and needless banter is pointless.

Kind of reminds me of your response here in the Secret Hitler game we played:

I have to see reading that game and this one Joe was putting in infinite more game analysis

For those that didn't play that game, Trent played Fascist (Mafia equivilent) and JoeSapphire played Liberal (Town equivilent)

I meant DEDO. if you read the thing I quoted, Joe said Dedo, and I misquoted "blot."

I am aware that Blot was mislynched D1. I do not knowwhy I seem to confuse "Dedo" with "Blot", but I do. My apologies to both Dedo & Blot.

Your quote attributes Microfish instead of Trent -_-'

The only thing I can think is initially it didn't post with the quote/post numbers because they were higher than the posts on this thread so I changed the quote numbers to be lower and it then posted. It must have changed the poster name as a result

Takeaway: Trent was the poster and not Microfish - Micro didn't play that game.

1) Huh. Reminder, in case you have more time.
2) Yes, thanks.
3) Less IRL duties, more time, I felt I finally had something so I went with it, as opposed to merely gathering evidence.

@Pooka, I hadn't realized I stood a chance at being in your gov in SH; maybe I could have, I'll take your word for it. And yes, playstyles evolve. I was lunched in my first game for being "too analytical". If being less analytical in my posts lets me survive longer, and have fewer headaches IRL, it's win-win and I'm all for it. My scum game maybe lost us the game, but I disagree with scene's playstyle somewhat--based off of Zeo's successful "Castle In the Sky" play.

He raises a good point about Trent, I think.

Am willing to lunch
Scene
Flub
Trent

Unsure, leans town:
Dedo
Joe
Book

Not willing to lunch yet:
Pooka
Gogtrial
Micro

If you are genuinely Town I'm not sure this is positive. Town players need to solve the game together. You weren't 'lunched' you were Night Killed because you were a town asset.

If you are Town do you see why some Town players may find your differing Town play suspicious?

you are correct, it was a NK. I misspoke, sorry.
I see it as "I might survive longer and do a bit more good than if I burn brightler and burn out/am snuffed out"

I do, but I've also publicly said in 2-3 places that I won't be playing that intensely again.

Another rough day.


Yeah, it was indeed Scene's quote even though that wasn't the point. Anyway, I probably botched some quote formatting while cleaning up my post. Sorry about that.


It's time to act but I'm a bit unsure what to do. I'm considering joining Scene's wagon. I have to admit that among all other things one part of me just wants to be remove the question mark and finally know the answer. The will hopefully end or at least it will become a bit simpler.


I believe my vote on Scene would put him on L-1. Considering we have his claim already is there something else that anyone (including Scene) would like to consider and bring up? L-1 can turn into a lynch very abruptly, voluntarily or not (trust me, I know) so if anyone has something to say I'll hold a bit longer (probably until tomorrow morning).

Just seeing dedo's post. I have a vote for scene to L-1 all written up. Want to finish a roundup post before posting it. Here's head's up so we don't get an accidental hammer.