This makes me think Micro is scum.
This makes me think micro is town.
This is an unexpected reaction, but I don't know what to make of it.
Do you want me to?
I'm not voting for bookwyrm because I think his rally against a town powerrole refusing to acknowledge the positives to NOT lunching that powerrole was too audacious for scum.
Bookwyrm, Dedo, Trent - in the last game we played it got mentioned a few times that Bookwyrm's scum game is quite obvious and easily recognisable to Yogsloth and dedo among others. I've been assuming that tearing out of the woodwork thirsting for town roleblocker's blood is something that mafiesque bookwyrm wouldn't do. Is that the case?
Ugh. Overall I think I want to unvote microfish.
Oop, yeah I remember this...
1) Joke/sarcastic OMGUS, my vote was quickly removed as soon as someone else gave reason for me to vote them. It was a poke to see your reaction.
2) Lift hisself said [para] "NEVER LIE! ONLY SCUM HAVE A REASON TO LIE! VOTE ALL LIARS!"[/para] I took this into account when GR couldn't provide the evidence to back up his claims.
4) It was a mild question seeking opinions. Nice observations, and I think i would agree that no scum would advocate for not killing a town PR.
4b) You should, if you haven't already as I write this.
5) Thank you for remembering this. Sadly, 'tis true.
Now to be fair to scene, you, Microfish, have played with him while both of you were scum in Secret Hitler. Not Mafia, but the premise of "clueless majority versus informed minority trying to hide among the clueless majority" is present in both games. He probably took that game into account as well.
I don't recall you being in favor of Joe's wagon, maybe a reread will show it.
The entirety of the GameRager saga began with scene voting Joe followed by GameRager (who thought scene was scum) voting Joe!
Re-reading and I think Joe is Mafia:
<...scene's reasons, sea original post...> VOTES JOESAPPHIRE
followed by...three posts later:
GameRager: Vote JoeSapphire PookaMustard:
(Be aware that I am doing it mainly to see if you are scum trying to get town lynched, and if he is proven town and gets lynched I will have my sights on you the next day)
Now I'll grant you that scene wasn't on Joe's wagon at EOD, instead opting for GR. But I mean, come on, scene initiating the Joe wagon was the precursor to GR and his weird play.
Honestly, I'm not sure which of you two worry me more.
1. Eh, he says he didn't.
Thank you for the recap & clarification. I had forgotten when I was half-asleep writing the post you quoted.
It was a joke. I'm sorry you didn't pick up on it.
- his saying blahblahblahblah and refusing to engage logically with me I did take personally, despite him telling me not to.
I'm cool with talking and new ideas up until around 24 hours before deadline. I'm not cool with someone tossing something new out there right at deadline; all too often it leads to a confused scramble and pushes the risk of No Lynch way up.
If you want to propose things like No Lynch, then don't do it when we're up against the deadline. Do it when there is time to actually talk about it, and scum have to actually work at responding instead of taking advantage of EOD confusion and rush.
If you want to push someone close enough to lynch that they'll claim, then try not to wait until deadline to do it. Etc.
AHA I found it. It was Pooka's alarm that supplementscene's wagon grew to 5 strong in a short space of time early Day 1.
You remember? And then he warned blotunga off it, and blotunga stepped back and then we all lunched blotunga and it turned out blotunga was town and Joe was wrong? And then SirP and Carr got shot. Ah those were simpler times...
Do I still think that Pooka must be town based on that? Hm... I wouldn't like to say he's incapable of a complex deception, but it would be so easy to turn a blind eye or take a less strong hand in the matter.
Microfish - how's Pooka's Secret H game? Has he been practising outwardly L appearance to disguise his F nature a lot lately? Or anything?
I bumped dedo up a bit after his response to me about bookwyrm. I got thinking "okay I'll trust dedo's read" and then I thought "why??" and then I thought "I just do."
^ The brain of Joe, quantified.
Sadly, I've only played with Pooka as L, never as H. Thus, I can't really answer. We ran around in circles, and I played horribly. However, FWIW, he seems like he is playing similarly--if far less active--then he did in the 3-week SH game. I think. Enough that I read him as town.
Why do you trust Scene so much? As I illustrated earlier, his logic is leading him to erroneous conclusions. The logic train just doesn't make it. Or, he's scum and desperately trying to get a townie executed. I can see zero other alternatives.
Why base you trust of blot off of "I just do?" Are you masons together? (If you are scum, please trip up and blurt it out. That would be extremely helpful, kind, and the jolly-good right thing to do. Thanks.)
FWIW, when I don't have solid suspicions, I try to just nose around calmly and inoffensively, gathering data from the on-deck circle. I only step up to the plate when I have what I feel are solid evidences or suspicions.
@Pooka, when I was F, if you recall, I was attacking Zeo (I also have a hard time seeing him as a sheep, but whatever) from the get-go. I was swinging from the very start, trying to sow confusion in discord. This time I didn't bother voting until #305. i didn't even vocalize suspicions until #204. How can you see this as being scum!me when it is so different from "try to confuse everyone with wild claims from the very start!Micro"? You know better. You know
you know better. So does scene, if he wasn't scum. In fact, I think *ANYONE* from that game would notice the difference.
Yay for town doing way more damage to ourselves than mafia is capable of. The day frustrates, but the results of these nights amuse me!
Going to be catching up now.
FYI: Real life is making me be much less present than I'd prefer to be. Keeping a close eye to see how bad it gets (nothing truly bad irl - just a lot
of it to deal with); I really hope I can avoid having to ask for a replacement.
1) Why "amuse"? this seems like an odd word. Sadden--that we took the wrong guy to lunch is one thing. Joy that all town survived is another. Why "amuse"
I hope life is better soon. You could always ask for a sub for that? :O
Other stuff, which I will huh. at, but not enough to comment on with "unique" comments.