From your vantage point of a leaf in the wind, do you have any thoughts about Bookwyrm, GameRager, microfish, and Pooka? Would you leave flub for any of them?

I was pointing to you as an example, not to reprimand you for it :T

What of blotunga that gets him your vote? I noticed he's been pretty much absent in the last two pages (50 posts per page). I think it's worth re-enabling Adalia Fundamentals and doing a quick ISO on him.

I've already shared my concerns and feelings on the matter. I'd rather not repeat myself unless you really insist but I strongly hope you didn't skip what I wrote so far.

Alright, I ISO'd blotunga. And you while I was at it. I noticed that I didn't answer a previous question of yours, thanks GOG. Or my ISP. Both work I guess!

Unlike last time, I am waiting to see if there are two night kills or just one. By being preoccupied with it last time, I only made myself look worse and had people asking the very question you asked here. As you said, it is probable at a fifty-fifty chance, so we'll see.

----
Back to blotunga. Incidentally, I haven't seen much of town!Blotunga. Maybe in the Secret Hitler game, but my favorable investigation result of him got him executed first thing. In the Joe game, he was Mafia, and I don't even recall if he was in last game, for I was the first nightkill and wasn't putting much effort in staying up to date with the game.

Personally, I think he hesitated? He has a point, but not the way he said it. Rather than fish for reactions in the RVS stage, I think he is interested in the reactions to what's going with scene and his wagon, before Day 1 ends. Still, bringing scene to L-2 this early on would have achieved the exact opposite of what he hoped for, and if he just got even preoccupied with real life for an hour, two other votes could have hammered scene.

I still think scene is a more viable wagon, firstly because he seems scummy, what's with suggesting that the Mafia Wiki would benefit mafia more than town. Doesn't help that he's sure gogtrial is scum, though I have to look into this a little deeper.

Come Out, Come Out, Wherever You Are!

Besides your own wagon and scene's wagon, what do you think has been the most significant development in this game so far?

Which three players do you find hardest to read?

Nice, but please be careful not to edit your posts when playing. :)

=======================

I wouldn't want town to lose but this is just how I play. I have trouble following all the nomenclature/all the posts and do my best, I also don't usually keep info sheets like some do(though I should), so I sometimes misquote/miswrite when posting too much in such games and that's another reason why I avoid posting much(and another reason I should make an info sheet).



=======================

BTW is trent the one in the lead for lynch/why did you vote for them? I ask to understand your reasons for voting for them and also because I think i'd rather we lynched someone rather than no one to at least get a chance at hitting scum today/tonight/etc.


Are you asking for this game or in general? Because you seemed to be knowledgable on the game in general when I asked earlier....this seems odd for you to ask, is what i'm saying.

If you're genuinely curious: They could act as town and start a wagon going and get others to join in presumably.


I am not sure on anyone but at this point i'd be willing to vote you(as closest to lynch) just to perhaps get a scum lynched and not end in a nolynch.

I will gladly vote for whomever seems scummiest before day ends, or the one with the highest count to see if we can lynch a scum and not end in nolynch(as as far as I know from old games that is bad for town, right?).

FoS. But I'll grant you reprieve for the moment due to effectively being a newbie.

Don't do it "before day ends". Do it now! We want a permanent record of your strongest suspicion. And don't vote for the majority consensus, vote for your beliefs. We understand that you are uncertain, that you really don't know anything for certain, but the pressure is on! Everyone is watching you! You have to decide if you want to vote your scum buddy, to create distance, or risk losing your team mate. CHOOSE WISELY! And choose now!

There's still plenty of time to do the slow shuffle of forming consensus on viable wagons after that, but that process only works if everyone is actually voting instead of waiting for everyone else until deadline arrives.

Moar voting from you, too!

Alright, if you say so. I'll put my money where my mouth is.

VOTE SUPPLEMENTSCENE

It's a bit odd that you voted scene right after me.....got a feeling/proof or what?

I just received the notification from Galaxy, and I also refresh this thread's tab every few minutes, to compensate for my lack of activity the previous days.

Vote Count

(When you see a vote count please quickly make sure your vote is against the correct player. Let me know if it's not)

scene 5 - Bookwyrm, gogtrial, trent, GameRager, Pooka
blotunga 3 - JoeSapphire, flub, dedoporno
trent 2 - agentcarr, scene
JoeSapphire 1 - SirPrimalform
flub 1 - blotunga

Everyone else - 0
Not voting: Micro

13 players left. It takes 7 to lynch.
scene is closest at L-2

Oh, I totally forgot about that as it was somewhat tongue-in-cheek but thanks for answering. At least now I know you went back and read my posts. Speaking of which, why didn't you do that in the first place (if you actually didin't, that is)?

I haven't based my suspicion on meta in this case since I also haven't played a tremendous amounts of games with him to be able to form some sort of expectation. It's based on his vote/unvote and subsequent explanation of his motivations and the way they were presented. All of that with a sprinkle of uneasiness in my gut, although I can't be 100% sure about that last bit.

Ok then.....but you didn't say why you voted for them. :)