Posted April 28, 2017
Bookwyrm627: I won't be blocking a lynch on a dead player. I had planned to derail a D2 Dessimu lynch if he wasn't the N1 kill, which would have risked my own head. Assume Dessimu had survived N1; the obvious logic (and already laid out at the end of D1) is that after his claim, he only survives N1 if he's scum.
If I were scum and Dessimu were town, I'd have let the doctor try to protect Dessimu while I go out and kill two other people. Target Dessimu for the D2 lynch and clean up his investigations (if necessary) on a later Night.
I put in the assumption that Dessimu was town from the point of view of entering N1. Townies didn't have proof of his being town at that time.
Lifthrasil: I see. Thanks for clarifying. If I were scum and Dessimu were town, I'd have let the doctor try to protect Dessimu while I go out and kill two other people. Target Dessimu for the D2 lynch and clean up his investigations (if necessary) on a later Night.
I put in the assumption that Dessimu was town from the point of view of entering N1. Townies didn't have proof of his being town at that time.
@trent: really? No lynch over lynching yogs? And that after all the talk in all the past games about no-lynch being usually very, very bad for town on Day 1? What made yogs so towny to you that you would have preferred a no-lynch with no information for town over losing him? And while you're at it, please also answer my other questions: WHY did you see Dessi as so scummy that you were willing to risk mislynching a PR? And how exactly did cristi 'set you up'?
Dessimu felt off to me most of he day so I felt he was scum. The fact that he claimed a PR before his lynch meant bubkis because if he had been scum he would have done the same thing.
I don't expect you to acknowledge how your scum buddy cristi was setting me up, it would make her look bad if you did.