Cavalary: The ToS doesn't say anything about multiple accounts from what I can see. tomyam80 found that it's forbidden on the forum, but multiple accounts when one doesn't post on the forum wouldn't be covered by that.

As for rule 16, I'd go with anything. Of course, only very minor donor so doesn't count for much. For simplicity, would also lean most towards making it clear that the game must be redeemed on the account that asks (or is nominated) for it, no exceptions. But can see some point in some arguments for all other 3 options too (a single designated alt account for those who use it, donor choice whether it must be redeemed by the account that asks or is nominated or not necessarily, or zeo's way of allowing even some cases of one using up their game of the month to ask for it to be sent to another). Give me a single-choice poll and I'd vote for that simple option, but ask what I'd be ok with and I'd say any.

tomyam80: May i know where u c the ToS? Personally wat i read simply means no other account other than ur own (on the forum or not) & regardless of whether 1 uses the other account/s in the forum but that's just my interpretation.

gogtrial34987: Is the alt-account-for-privacy case something we've actually encountered in the wild

Cavalary: Uhhuh.

gogtrial34987: With the "we" bit, I meant here, for this giveaway. I have no doubt people exist who have multiple accounts for different purposes, but has anyone ever requested a game for the purpose of redeeming it with their alt-account? That'd still "leak" the existence of that alt-account (tied to someone who's active enough on the forum to qualify for the giveaway), which'd kinda defeat the purpose of having a secret alt account.

Korotan: Is Avernum Escape from the Pit still available?

finkleroy: Not anymore, it's not, because it's just been...
Granted.

finkleroy: To my knowledge, this has only been done by one user. I'm starting to think the best course of action is to change the rule to say that the keys must be redeemed by the account that requested them, and then grandfather in this one user. What does everyone think of that?

finkleroy: Granted.

finkleroy: What does everyone think of that?

Gekko_Dekko: btw - I remember old giveaway having a thing called "anonymous donors". E.g if you want to donate something, but dont wanna have your nick in list of donors, or mentioned after gift was received. Is it still a thing there?