In that case, I guess it wasn't a total waste.

My total haul, some stuff I wanted but I think I am done.

We are the Dwarves
Throne of Darkness
Stories Untold
Pilot Brothers
Meridian: New World
Darksiders II: Deathinitive Edition
Bombshell
Metro 2033 Redux
Pinstripe
Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons
Metro: Last Light Redux
Saints Row: Gat out of Hell
Imperium Galactica
Darksiders Warmastered Edition
Skyshine's BEDLAM Deluxe Edition
Her Story
Republique
Saints Row IV: Game of the Century Edition

I bought nine pinata - four duplicates, but that's my own fault for having 1,754 Steam games (and a few on other platforms).

That said, the ones I did not yet have look half-decent:

Duplicates
King's Bounty: The Legend
Kyn
S.T.A.L.K.E.R. - Shadow of Chernobyl (actually, this one is triplicate!)
SoulBringer *DUPLICATE


Star Wolves 3: Civil War
Drox Operative
Dead Synchronicity: Tomorrow Comes Today
Political Animals
Gratuitous Space Battles 2

Not sure about the gratuitous one, but the others tend towards decent reviews. Political Animals was one I had not heard of, but would probably have gone onto my wishlist if I had.

Check your PMs, and thanks GOG for converting the pinata!

I bought 4 and received the following:

Capitalism 2 (wont play it myself but it looks like a building game and my 9yr son loves them. He still plays sim city for snes)

Conquests of Camelot (at this point i was getting worried that i wasted my money)

Baldurs gate enhanced edition (i played the original edition for many hours but never beat it. One of disks became scratched so bad i couldn't finish. Looking forward to a replay)

Blackguards Special Edition (I love turn based strategy so this suits me.)

Overall happy with my games only 1 big dud but that's how gambling works.

Yesterday: Holy Potatoes! A Weapon Shop?!
Today: Bombshell

So for the 4 pinatas I bought I got

RIME
Capitalism 2
Hard West
Dreamfall Chapters: The Final Cut

Not a bad haul really.

Another go, got....

Randal's Monday
Deponia 3: Goodbye Deponia
Pilot Brothers
Depths of Peril
Democracy 3: Africa
Throne of Darkness
Caesar II
Caesar™ IV
Kim
The Whispered World: Special Edition
------------------- added more----------------
Caesar
Shivah
Tetrobot and Co.
Enter the Gungeon
BLACKHOLE
Caravan
The Inner World
1954 Alcatraz
SOMA
Slave Zero
--------------- again -----------------------
Space Rangers: Quest
Homeworld: Emergence
Cossacks 3
Krush Kill ‘N Destroy 2: Krossfire
Blood 2: The Blood Group
The Adventures of Willy Beamish
Hacknet
Codename: ICEMAN
Edna & Harvey: The Breakout
Imperium Galactica II: Alliances

I got

Crawl (fun but I don't really do couch co-op anymore)
Kim (looks like a game I'll play for and hour and forget)
Untold stories (only game that I got that I had a desire for)
Redshirt (frankly looks bad, very poor looking characters)

Overall it wasn't bad it was random so I can't get mad at anyone but myself for gambling but it was only 3$ a shot it's not a bad deal

Purchased four pinatas:

•Agatha Christie: The ABC Murders
•Back to the Future: The Game
•Dead Synchronocity: Tomorrow Comes Today
•Mount & Blade: Warband

I already had Back to the Future from a previous purchase on TellTale's page, but it's nice to have it here. Overall very satisfied with today's gamble.

List updated

Today's Piñata: IL2-Sturmovik

There are six games on the spreadsheet that i really wanted .

Caesar IV
CivCity: Rome
Craft The World
Day of the Tentacle Remastered
Freddy Pharkas: Frontier Pharmacist
Full Throttle Remastered

I see one you missed.
Post 754 of this thread
Anomaly 2