The problem(imo) with that strategy(just saying one is town, sans other info, instead of lying to cover a PR & claiming vanilla) is that the town with a PR could get lynched while away/offline or they could post their PR later on and not be believed...leading to them getting lynched anyways.

And afaik you're right on the method you said being the "accepted" way people do it(at least it is here, afaik).....I still don't think it's the best way to hide a PR when being asked to claim, though.

Because if other town believed it and dropped wanting to lynch that town player then that player's PR would be safe, scum likely wouldn't know about it, and the town PR player would still be alive.

(Dunno if the above makes any sense, as sometimes I fail to find the right words to express my intent and ideas.....also to me my idea still seems to make logical sense: i.e. to lie sometimes like that in order to give town advantages)

Eh, different sites play games differently sometimes...maybe he's more used to other ways of playing and better suited for them? Or maybe he has off games sometimes? Who knows.

Eh, to me his play style seems NAI atm.

(Will post the SH link there in a bit)

Like this kinda emoji? ---> o.0

I want ANY town on board and kept alive if they can help us vote for and lynch scum...regardless of many possible "bad aspects" they might have(barring some exceptions) they might bring to the table/game.

Also dunno if both are town, but let's say we lynch one....should we lynch the other the next game day or what? At some point town need to scum hunt and not just eliminate "bad players" or distractions, and that goes for most games of mafia in general imo.

Don't I merit at least a few more by now? O.0

----------------------------

(Aside: I also like the way you're adding flavor between us in our back and forth here....very nice to read)
===================================================

I get you have your own style, but if I may speak openly I think your LAL/lynch all bad players thing can also hinder town.

Imo town need to do things town don't normally do(as long as it's within the rules or too "bastardy" maybe) to win, especially for any town who claim to be playing to win(I mean in general, not just this game).

I agree 100% that pointing out possible PRs and some of his other actions are suspect(and a bit unwise) though, and if no one better comes up I likely will vote him later on.
=============================================

(Done for now....going out in about a half hour to do IRL stuff, and will be back an hour and a half or more after that)

Both? That's not possible.

Very possible. If one of them got dayvigged.

You mistook me it seems....I also see that as slightly suspect(what laser did re: PRs)....I just don't want to vote them for just that and some other minor things...at least atm. If no one else better comes up(as said in my prior post) I will likely vote them as well and hope for the best.
===============================

If laser wasn't day vig then it is possible, if day vig is someone else and offs one of them.

I just read the sample PM for the dayvig and...their kill command ends the Day and instantly advances into the Night rather than continue the Day. I was going off my memory when bookwyrm was a dayvig recently.

So essentially...it's a Supervote. Nothing better. And thus, not possible as you said.

Oh, Miss Pookina! You're suggesting a day wig for a second time now. I'm very tempted to grab YOUR.BIG.BUTT...on that beautiful dress of yours and rip it off!

What if the day vig did it right at the hammer of the day's lynchee? I wonder....would it count and both of them be offed?
------------------------------------------

@Joe: Joeeeeeeeeeeeeee, what is your reply to the above.....if a day vig day vigged at the exact moment the hammer vote fell would both offings be counted(lynch and vig) or no?

It is a musical. Appart from the movies there are live performances, which are the true raison d’être for these works.

The looks in this piece, and other details, suit GOG’s Restaurant, Runyon and Joe Broadway’s stories better.

Did you check the actual subtitles? Hint, hint. Find comment there ^_^ I am betting you that the one in the older movie had different ones.

Did not post them as they are better taken in as a surprise.

Might do it later in case someone wants to sing along, or cannot watch videos because it would be NSFW or any other reason.

(Clue: it goes in the line of Toss a coin to your lyncher, from the Harry Potter game, only with actual subtitles this time).
===========

As per the other news:

The Lift finally showed up. I was expecting a thundering storm about the imposture of a power role. The actual reaction seemed just lukewar, but still he delivered a vote consistent with whis play line. If it stays, it will look all the better for him.

The Cookie started bold, then cooled her heels, as she met strong opposition early. Time will show what her next moves are.

Scenes seems distrated. Especially since people keep saying he is a competent player. Distracted and buying crappy logic. Due to RL issues (I am ready to believe that) or some other resason. But he changed the course. Is it distancing or just waking up to the game.

Walkins, scum or not, is hurting Town. If Town, he is forcing Town to deal with him, instead of focusing on someone else. Scum doing what he is doing might be offering themselves as a lightning rod to protect others in the team. Only that he does not seem to be a team player.

Cristine did not show up, IIRC. Lurked for most of the last game-day, then came in aggressively. She placed a vote on Games O’Rager. I would beg the question of whether she actually played with O’Rager before. If she knows Games, she ought to know that he actually loves writing and interacting, regardless of his alignment. This is the reason why I was buying his RL excuse for being mostly absent on Day 1 (not the case with Lift but I was ready to buy it as well). But Cristine went after him. That seemed a tad opportunistic. She bought Walkins’s and Scenes’s logic, no questions posed. She defused Zeffer’s drive against Walkins, and that is when Walkins really saved his skin on Day one, and Mike the Fish bought lottery tickets for a whole lote of round holes. Now that even Scenes retracted on his prior judgment of Walkins, what will her approach be? Actually, if she is scum, she does not need to be scum with any of them at all. She might have helped Scenes/Walkins survive in order to maintain a distraction, both for the lunch invites and for the (admittedly limited by the number of real game turns) Cop investigative actions. All this is speculative, of course, and she might have good reasons for his actions. Surely she will eventually appear and explain, and even share her views. Did they change? Was O’Rager a placeholder vote, waiting for the proper time to go after someone else?

Zeffer Briilliant player, will be missed. Very nice to have around, too. He was after Walkins, then he got stopped in his tracks by Cristine, who played with the notion of him having a bias against Lazy. When he changed his vote, that bandwagon lost its momentum. Now people has jumped on that same bandwagon. Is it too wild to speculate that he might be vocally considering the merits of said bandwagon, possibly jumping in? I think, that with Zeffer on board, it might have been successful. The question her is: Is it too soon for the interest of the Mob to have Walkins burned? Would not he be more useful as a decoy in the late game?

So, yes, there is a risk that we are being herded, cajoled, fooled, however you want to say it, into following distractions instead of hunting the actual scum. OR is that what they want us to think. Scenes/Walkins might be the plan B for distraction (plan A being taking to lunch someone else like Micro). Although there is always the chance that someone is hiding in plain sight. Especially someone boasting ballsy play.

So, notions incomplete as of now. Anyone is welcome to chime in and offer complementary views.

(Link above is song by Weird Al....seems appropriate for the setting/location we're in...enjoy, everyone :) )

Please be notified, I posted something here and it was not posted at all. GR made a bump here, also with no result. Be careful with double posting just in case, and save your messages in notepad.

Bump.

Yes, lost some posts in the past. Not fun if they are long.

Ah yes, I was going to say something similar in reply to your previous post but you've already got it.

They can't happen at the same moment. There's a clear chronology in the thread... Whichever happens first happens first.

Yeah... a mood kill.

How soon is a continuation of your analysis? Good points on Cristine, the vote on GR was odd even if she had played with him before and genuinely pictured him as Mafia that day.

I still don't get how and why ZFR suddenly changed his mind on Laser. I even suspected him of being Mafia. And his dying (not dying but last) wish was to lynch Scene on D2, but all are we doing now is exactly what I asked for on D1: persecution of Laser, I even asked for a modkill > a *salivating* person, most probably Mafia, how Laser put it. Laser practically saved Scene by *fake kill* on D1 (and we lost 1-2 Town because of him), he is saving him again toDay by doing crazy stuff. But even if they both Mafia we HAVE to find at least one more toDay.

I don't like your analysis on Miss Pookina and Mr. Large the Lift. If Lift is elusive and very silent yet quite aggressive towards *liars*, Pookina said some interesting things (e.g. *if I was a day wig, I would shot you right now*, *we can kill both, lynch one and day wig can shot the other one*), and her dress is SO revealing.

Your Scene analysis almost look like a soft push in clearing him. Hmm? Why would Laser risk his life 2 times for him?

I might have something to add later. (I have something right now, but I want to have a break and for once to use all the words in proper order as much as possible)

You definitely should add analysis on yourself.

Lastly, we have lurkers among us, quite many.

P.S. I re-watched the video, this time with captions ;)))

You asked for it, woman!
*spanking Pookina buttocks hard* - I want you to know I'm feeling worse than you (and my hand hurts)

What have you done? Laser is half-way lynched anyway, damn it! Do you know what ZFR would have said about it? *What a moronic way to reveal a role!*. And I agree on that completely.