flubbucket: I know we have several “new” players in this game (Leonard03, Bookwyrm627, cristigale). I know cristigale started another game and had to drop out early so I’m not really counting it. Regardless there are players with sort of a soft spot for NOT lynching/NKing new players on Day/Night One. I’m listing Robbeasy, adaliabooks, Sage103082, and to be honest myself in this group.
Now this isn’t to say others aren’t also possible candidates, or that I’m even correct, it’s just speculative reasoning why trentonlf was chosen as NK target.
Also this isn’t a “scum list” but merely reasoning out or sorting out in hopes something bubbles to the top.
Now A_Future_Pilot hadn’t played a game in some time but that didn’t seem to be a hindrance to his lynch on Day One; other than the hammering appeared to be drawn out as some players have commented. I can see yogsloth, JMich, HijacK, Lifthrasil, Robbeasy, and myself willing to NK trentonlf in order to keep the game flowing instead of waiting for a replacement to catch up. That can be a real drag on game momentum.
I see HypersomniacLive, Sage103082, Bookwyrm627, adaliabooks, Leonard03, cristigale more likely wanting to NK a power role.
I don't know. Perhaps I'll make a chart.....
I meant to address this early but forgot.
While I kind of see where you are coming from, and agree with some of your assessments...
I would generally agree that I give the newbies a bit more leeway, and am less likely to lynch or NK someone in there first game, but I was more than happy to NK Bookwyrm night 1 last game due to his quite townie nature at the end of the day. And I was also more than happy to kill RWarehall when he was to be replaced if it would have helped Lift.
Also... cristi didn't drop out of a game, she played right through till being lynched (and then NK'd as she was 1 shot unlynchable) which you should really remember.. cause it was your game.. 0_o
Rereading this little assessment I can't quite see what you are getting at, especially as some of the info isn't accurate (and you should be aware of these inaccuracies)