Maybe I'm a bit biased because GameRager was scum in the only game I played with him and he did the same thing. Float around not making waves and offering to join any wagon that is the longest. At best, this makes it NAI (non-alignment determinative), but it's still quite anti-Town. Man, would be great to be scum knowing you have an extra vote and all you have to do if bring a mislynch to the top.

As to the rest of you, I don't know what to make out of it. It just reminds me of Town v Town as people are all looking for any little thing to vote for that seems a little off and two or more aggressive scum-hunters end up pointing fingers at each other. Of course looking at the bigger picture with all the votes flying around, most of it is Town v Town even if a scum (or 2) might have gotten stuck in the middle of it. The question is who might be the trapped scum? Or are they not trapped and joining on the fringe?

The only thing I feel reasonably certain about is that scum are very unlikely to both be voting for the same person. I highly doubt they would be actively working together at this early point in the game so I can mostly rule out scum teams of RFG + Lift; ZFR + Joe; ZFR + Pooka; Joe + Pooka because I find it hard to believe scum will hitch their wagons together for fear of being associated. Even if one of Joe or Lift are scum, you likely have 1 scum on the other wagon and one off not voting or voting someone else. If both are Town their votes might be anywhere. From completely staying out of it to joining a wagon to appear Townly.

But specifically, about Joe, I don't know what to make of this. Everything I see says no scum would possibly expose himself this much, yet I've been told he's done similarly as scum in the past with random declarations of the scum team. I'm not persuaded by his argument that this is a great plan because HE knows he's not scum so the odds become 2 in 9. Simply because it's illogical since none of us (I guess besides scum) will know he's Town. Frankly, I like the initial ploy as a good scum-hunting conversation starter. Is he Town and the ploy spun a bit out of control?

As to Lift, yeah I thought some of his early posts might be opportunistic shading, but it looks like scum hunting and possibly conversation starting too. I don't know. I've just seen too many games where the scum laugh themselves to the bank watching with popcorn as town eats their own knowing tomorrow's lynch will likely be the person on the other side. In other words, if neither Lift nor Joe are scum, we are very likely to mislynch today and then mislynch the other tomorrow. I can't tell you how many games play out this way.

Question for both Joe and Lift...
Assume you are both Town, who do you think the scum team would be?

So it would seem. My eldest boy brought something home and it looks I got it. I've had fever for the last 48 hours and it's damn annoying. Everything hurts and I have almost no energy to do anything.

Thank you, I hope it will past quick.


Doesn't he look different to you from when we were scum together and kept using GR as a scapegoat for like 3 days? He is an easy lynch since his play is indeed [somewhat] anti-town but will that provide anything to work with if he turns out a mislynch? At this point the only positive I see is to remove a general concern so we can have a peace of mind (which isn't a bad thing) so I will vote him out to avoid no-lynch.


I've never played with him when he was scum. So he plays like this even as scum? OK, that makes me feel a bit better then.

Game #61 is you feel like going through it for comparison.

Good points....I guess I just want to help town win as much as I can, and since I am often not thorough enough to help with analysis I try my best to help in other ways like hopefully hitting scum when I can.

I do it in every game for quite awhile now.....it's not just particular to this game.

I will likely vote in a bit based in a few posts(which I will also list later when I do so).....probably in an hour or maybe 2.
============================

And npw we have a deadline...ok then, I will definitely vote.....but should I vote for the current wagon or one of my choices.....

(Again[to all], I will likely do so in a bit...1-2 hours)
=============================

As I have said here and in other threads, I have poor memory IRL....that combined with me not taking many notes in these games leads to me making mistakes sometimes.
==============================

1st bit: Yeah, that sounds like what I had....my advice as others likely would tell you is to drink plenty of(non-alcoholic) fluids, eat well to keep up your strength, avoid extremely cold temps, use some OTC medicine to limit symptoms so you can do other things while you wait it out.

2nd bit: Here's hoping......

I'm getting the feeling he's trying to avoid being lynched, and in doing so, he slipped and gave his wagon more importance than the leading Lift wagon despite the smaller vote count.

If he turns out to be a mislynch, you can expect at least one of the scum to be on his wagon. I doubt all of them would stay on the wagon, and doubt all of them would not be on it. But to be honest, I'd still rather have Lift lynched today.

Also, I hope you and your family get better! Cold is not an easy thing. I hate it :[

Duly noted. I'll try to do that next time I get the chance.

Right now, Joe would be my top pick for scum. What bothers me is questioning whether he'd be crazy enough as scum to draw that much attention to himself.

I'm not sure about Lift. I don't find any one argument against him particularly compelling, I just wonder whether he's scum trying to defeat town by a thousand cuts.

Lynching Pooka would be a bad idea at this moment. He's put suspicions on enough people that he'll either be confirmed town or an easy to pick out second scum. I don't see Scum!Pooka being on a team with ZFR, Lift, Joe, or RWarehall. (Drawing a bit on RW's post, thanks for that)

GameRager, it's easier to read your alignment when you post more. I haven't really seen anything this game that's not the way GR normally plays, however the only tip-off that time when he was scum was his not posting as much.

Hot whiskey.

Eh, the whole "be yourself" movement is a sham. :P

I'd ask what you mean by a "good wagon", but I see that has been asked and answered already.

I'd say you were a liar and lynch you, of course.

This....if I get lynched check the wagon, people.
==========================

Yeah, iirc I was by myself and didn't know how to handle it at that time....of course there are other times I will post less, like if IRL issues come up/etc.

Also at that time I was sharing one of my PCs with someone else and had limited hours per day to post. I have much more time on this new PC per day(as it's in my name). Still, I only usually stay on so long per day then I sleep around 9+ hours(some of that time is getting to sleep and waking up afterwards).
=========================

We(family) also use(d) that remedy....though usually with such illnesses one should limit their alcohlic intake to a lesser amount for various reasons iirc.
==========================

Eh, it works better for me than "be the ball". o.0
============================
To all: I don't know who to vote for, so I will vote lift and hope we hit scum(I don't want to use random.org and I don't wanna vote myself[I still hold out hope I can live a day more] for now....sorry Lift.

Vote Lifthrasil
============================

Thank you!


What did I lie about?

Have you actually only been lynched once in 25 games?

Uneasiness because it's kinda bizarre that people would go along with the guy who says "hey guys let's vote this guy for no reason." but that's also what I asked everybody to do so I oughta stick with it...

Ugh. Sickening ;p
If I'd known that I might have picked you over lift. But then who knows what would have happened next?


I drew attention to them both at the time, but I'm thinking of here:
https://www.gog.com/forum/general/forum_mafia_63_supernatural/post82

and here:
https://www.gog.com/forum/general/forum_mafia_63_supernatural/post135

Where you sort of take it for granted that my process is genuine. It's not that significant, but maybe it sticks out because I remember you saying a few times there was something off about me and I remember thinking to myself "Dedo always thinks there's something off about me, doesn't he? Or does he? Maybe he can just read me really well! Am I terrible at mafia? Is dedo mafia king?"
So it's dredging up these old insecurities.

well my question was "with our alternatives" At the time I wasn't convinced anyone was behaving scummy. I'm still not sure. It's not easy.


Pooka and GameRager have both put votes on lift's wagon, which is now winning the wagon race. If he's town then those votes don't look good. But Pooka could have voted me instead putting my wagon into lift's place, using my questionable tactics as an acceptable reason. Why not? Maybe he thinks mislynch Joe and Lifthrasil is still difficult to lynch, mislynch Lifthrasil and Joe is easier to lynch... possibly. I need to reread pooka perhaps... I'm more inclined to believe GameRager's vote is honest, but maybe not.
Dedo I feel like is my best friend at the moment, so maybe I'm being buddied supremely? 'pocketed' if you will.
I'd still like it to turn out that it's ZFR and Carr, but their behaviour hasn't really given anything away.

Maybe there are no mafia?.. What a twist!

Is that "Joe would be" as in I am your top pick, or "Joe would be, but" as in because of the 'is-he-crazy-enough' question I'm not?

What do you mean by this? Defeat by a thousand cuts? I'm not familiar with the expression, but also what is lifthrasil doing to warrant it?

I kind of like the rest of RedFireGaming's post... I sense he seeks to hunt scum.


Lift's encouraging GameRager to vote and then GameRager voting lifthrasil makes me again want to abandon ship, but without a trustier alternative it makes sense to continue on course... just imagine if it turns out I'm right!

Lift - if I do give in to my nerves and abandon your wagon, who should I vote instead of you?

If he turns out to be town then your votes and ZFR's would also be suspect.


Shamalamadingdong would be proud.

It's quite arrogant of you to write as if you knew how I think. Especially since you're wrong. Just because you used that 'strategy' as Scum doesn't mean that others would too. As scum, I wouldn't have a 'real target'. Why would you have a preferred target as Scum on D1? And why should that target be you? You're not that dangerous for Scum. That may change on later Days, but if you are Town, Scum will be quite happy with you at the moment.


Wait what? After lamenting that you don't want to lynch the wrong person you vote for a person you don't have any case against? Even apologizing in the process? ... I know I asked you to vote and in a way I got what I asked for. But the point is: if you are Town, you'll want to give you fellow Townies something to work with. Some thoughts and suspicion of your own. A 'meh, I'll just jump on the longest wagon' doesn't add anything of value. We're not that close to the deadline that that would be a necessity to avoid a no-lynch. So it's a scummy move. If you vote me, state why you think that I'm likely scum. I suspect that your vote is pure self-preservation. You were pointed to the fact, that my train is viable and so you do your part to make it more viable to avoid being lynched yourself. Right?

Well, time for an actual OMGUS vote then. Since this move was either very bad Town play or more likely Scum, who isn't able to make an own case, trying to preserve himself by joining the longest wagon. (And also my preferred target wagon isn't going anywhere) and I'll keep that vote there until you provide some own thoughts beyond "it's the longest wagon available".

unvote JoeSapphire
vote GameRager

I would suggest Pooka or GR. GR gives off the air of a flailing newbie who doesn't exactly know what he's doing. ... But here's the thing: he isn't. By now he is no Newbie anymore and he knows how this game works. So I think he might be scum using the 'I don't know what to do' schtick.

But I still have that uneasy feeling about Pooka. Only he has a grand total of 0 votes on him, so while others seemingly share that uneasy feeling, no one seems to be willing to vote for him today. If you really are Town and just wanted to provoke reactions with your unfounded vote on me, I suggest you take a look at Pooka and his reaction to the perceived threat I seem to have been for him.

@ZFR: I notice that you still have your RVS-vote on me. Why? Did it turn into a real vote? Then elaborate please. Or did you forget it there?

@all: I'm at L-2 now. It is custom to wait until L-1 to claim, but we frequently were too close to the deadline to make anything useful out of a claim. Leading either to a no-lynch or a mis-lynch. I don't want either, since frankly I don't want to BE today's mis-lynch. But a pre-mature claim does damage to Town too, because it gives Scum something to work with. So my question to all of you: should I claim at L-2? And when? ASAP? Or for example 24 hours before the deadline? What do you think.

You shouldn't claim yet imho. Not sure why people are ganging up on Lift so much, I feel him town right now.
At this point even though Pooka didn't had the right vibes, GR feels the most disturbing to me too. But not sure if we mis-lynch him will give us any info.

I'm still willing to lynch Pooka, but wanted to regather my thoughts. Joe does make me uneasy as for the rest, I don't have much time to summarise.

@GR, sorry bud but I'm not your mason buddy anymore, and Lift is right with his OMGUS.

vote GameRager