They weren't revealed at the time I investigated them, I just didn't know what to make of the names.
And well, I just outed you Mrs Henrietta, trentonlf_and_ZFR_may_be_in_cahoots, Akalo.

Anyway, I'm sure we can go on for a good while. But it's gotten late, and I have a very early start and a busy day tomorrow, so lets continue tomorrow evening to also give others a chance to catch up and speak their thoughts.

Goodnight, Henrietta!

It's just awfully convenient that you happened to investigate two people who have flipped and one person who has claimed. You don't actually have any info that could confirm your ability, which I pretty much expected as it's the only way to fake that claim.

Oh, and thanks to you I no longer think ZFR or Trent could be scum - there cannot be three remaining villains as the game would be over. ZFR and Trent are almost certainly on the same team and so must be heroes.

I completely agree that there's not much more for the two of us to discuss so I bid you good night "Andrew".

What are your thoughts on Hyper and SPF?

Yet according to you he got your name. So you cant deny his name obtaining ability.

What Im concerned about is he investigated people who ended up dead. Hmmm....
I wasnt sure why micro was NKed... But if hsl found micro's name+role on N2. Reason enough to kill him.

Why is HSL still not dead? Why go after me (assuming my protection got it). I think they assumed Id protect trent, and to be honest I flipped a coin (used random.org) between myself and him.

If SPF was the scum Id see him go after Koro who believes HSL and trent are town or after HSL.

I just caught up. I don't know what to think about HSL's revelations. I don't even have an idea what kind of information would a flavor cop get. I guess it's plausible that he will get our flavor names. Now why would SPF deny his name? And since there was no kill but HSL has visited SPF, he was either protected or HSL just did some other action on him. Since SPF claims he can't be protected, I'm guessing that HSL indees didn't tried to kill him. I'm not yet sure which, but one of them must be scum.

He... Nearly got my name so he must have an ability something along those lines. The Andrew instead of Andrea thing is really weird, I can't work out if it's deliberate, an error on HSL's part, an error on Joe's part or a deliberate flaw in HSL's power (he says he has no modifier, but some modifiers like naïve are more sensible if secret from the player).

Koro is actually one of my more certain town reads, by process of elimination and because of previous reads I expect blotunga to be the HSL's buddy.

This post is eerily familiar. It reminds me of blotunga's fence sitting when scene was busy exploding. This doesn't help much in terms of me vs HSL on the surface, but it makes me fairly confident that Blotunga is HSL's buddy.

Well this makes my decicion more or less easy. But I will wait before voting to see how the discussion is comming out.

Whoops, I meant to link to the post in question rather than my own post. I forgot to change the post number. Here's the link:

https://www.gog.com/forum/general/captain_sapphire_the_movie_gog_mafia_57/post666

You are right about this because then we would have 4 villains. His math would mayby go up if there is a traiter role but I think it whas counted as villain too.
If have two things to say about this post.
First what makes you think he would go after me? Sorry I just can not see the reasoning.
Second honestly I am not so sure about The Hypersomniac being one of us.

For arguing, we have two villains left. I am mostly convinced that InkBlot is not one of us but then the question is, who is the other one? Is it Serpent Rime or The Hypersomniac? The Canton Calf and you are both giving really good Alibis so mayby you are but then, what is InkBlots role? Is he just Troll or is he a traitor?
From my point of view the best way now would be to go after InkBlot because then we would get air up for solving this.

Of course it does, you've been trying to lynch me since day 1 almost.

@SPF if he got your gender wrong, maybe he thinks there is an information hidden in our genders. I have nothing against revealing my secret name if people think it can help.

@SPF, not every name has a modifier and trying to use that as an argument of someone’s guilt makes me doubt you even more.

For today my preferred lynch is blotunga, he’s the one I find most likely to be scum out of everyone.

Vote blotunga

When I saw my name at the beginning of the game, I read Andrea with the English feminine pronunciation. However Joe has been using he/him for Serpent Rime which lead me to one of two conclusions: my name is the masculine Andrea (e.g. Andrea Bocelli) or my name is feminine but my superhero identity presents as male (e.g. Princess Zelda and Sheik).

I don't recall arguing that a lack of modifier would make someone guilty, I was thinking that if HSL had a modifier it might explain how he got my name wrong when attempting to appropriate it. HSL being scum might have a reason to conceal or deny having a modifier but I have already retracted the statement about everyone having modifiers.

The only mention I've made of them since then is speculation as to why HSL got my name wrong when he stole it. If he has a hidden modifier it would explain a faulty result.

I'm fairly certain blotunga is scum, but naturally I'm 100% certain that HSL is scum. I would lynch blotunga, but as a distant second choice since I know HSL is a sure thing.