It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
trentonlf: How exactly would a doctor block someone???? I didn’t ask if someone protected somebody, but then again I know you don’t always think very clearly if at all.
avatar
supplementscene: A Doctor is a role that targets a player at Night to protect that player from a single kill made during that Night. They are not told if their protection was successful. Protection from a single kill means that if multiple players try to kill someone, they will not be saved by one Doctor's protection.
Are you being stupid on purpose?? I know what a doctor does and how his role works. I don't want to know if we have a doctor, I asked if anyone blocked someone last night. If you want to try and twist that to me asking who the doctor is if we have one at all go right ahead because that just affirms my thoughts on you being scum.
avatar
supplementscene: A Doctor is a role that targets a player at Night to protect that player from a single kill made during that Night. They are not told if their protection was successful. Protection from a single kill means that if multiple players try to kill someone, they will not be saved by one Doctor's protection.
avatar
trentonlf: Are you being stupid on purpose?? I know what a doctor does and how his role works. I don't want to know if we have a doctor, I asked if anyone blocked someone last night. If you want to try and twist that to me asking who the doctor is if we have one at all go right ahead because that just affirms my thoughts on you being scum.
You asked a question and received an answer. And why would you want a roleblocker to out themselves?
That prospect's scary. A night kill blocked on the first night. What are the odds?

So either way. We now know that, despite everything that has been said, Fran was actually a Hero. However, conveniently enough, we've been down to only 8 heroes (or 7 plus 1 serial killer if one is present) rather than 7. I sincerely wonder who was blocked from being night killed rather than who did it.

So about who to vote, know that before I put down my vote, I will have to more or less check over what's been said to see if they'll tell me something new with which I can assert or change my mind with. My choices for voting are as follows: SirPrimalform for being off in his responses and not divulging much, and scene for...I don't know, his arguments are hard to follow as it stands. And ZFR for immediately jumping on lynching me because of my jumping on the early scene wagon, which wouldn't have been a successful wagon to be honest.

I would need to get a closer look on Lift and trent. Especially Lift, since if the last game was any indicator, he was the perfect scum player (at least to me), so I'd like to ISO his postings to see if there's anything out of the ordinary for Town play. I'd suggest everyone with time to check him.

This leaves us with Microfishd, Korotan, dedoporno, Blotunga and HSL. Besides dedoporno who looks better to me now, the other four I want to get a better read on. One thing I'll give credit to HSL though; he's very attentive to detail and leaves nothing without questioning it.

Day 2 is going to be fun.
avatar
Lifthrasil: Why do you ask? Were you blocked tonight?

Or in other words: why do you assume the missing NK was due to a block and not due to some protection?
I don't want to know about any protective roles, I simply want to know if anyone blocked someone last night.


avatar
supplementscene: You asked a question and received an answer. And why would you want a roleblocker to out themselves?
Because if a role is in play that blocked someone last night it is a good chance that person they blocked is scum, how hard is that to understand. Just stop talking to me, you annoy me to no end with you dumbass remarks and comments.
avatar
trentonlf: Are you being stupid on purpose?? I know what a doctor does and how his role works. I don't want to know if we have a doctor, I asked if anyone blocked someone last night. If you want to try and twist that to me asking who the doctor is if we have one at all go right ahead because that just affirms my thoughts on you being scum.
avatar
supplementscene: You asked a question and received an answer. And why would you want a roleblocker to out themselves?
*If* it was an NK failure due to roleblocking, an RB can tell us who a scum is.

However I'm of the opinion that it's too early for them to reveal themselves. I'd rather they don't.

avatar
PookaMustard: And ZFR for immediately jumping on lynching me because of my jumping on the early scene wagon, which wouldn't have been a successful wagon to be honest.
Interesting. I wasn't on your table yesterday. Why the change of heart?
avatar
ZFR: *If* it was an NK failure due to roleblocking, an RB can tell us who a scum is.

However I'm of the opinion that it's too early for them to reveal themselves. I'd rather they don't.
If someone has information like that they should always share it. What happens if they don't share it and are killed at night or by a vigilante? Whatever knowledge they had dies with them. If someone believes they have found scum they should always come forth IMO.
avatar
Lifthrasil: Why do you ask? Were you blocked tonight?

Or in other words: why do you assume the missing NK was due to a block and not due to some protection?
avatar
trentonlf: I don't want to know about any protective roles, I simply want to know if anyone blocked someone last night.

avatar
supplementscene: You asked a question and received an answer. And why would you want a roleblocker to out themselves?
avatar
trentonlf: Because if a role is in play that blocked someone last night it is a good chance that person they blocked is scum, how hard is that to understand. Just stop talking to me, you annoy me to no end with you dumbass remarks and comments.
You're still upset about me correcting your grammar aren't you?
avatar
supplementscene: You're still upset about me correcting your grammar aren't you?
Your whole attitude gets under my skin. The less I have to talk with you or interact with you the better. So unless you have some in game related question of me just leave me alone and I'll leave you alone.
avatar
ZFR: *If* it was an NK failure due to roleblocking, an RB can tell us who a scum is.

However I'm of the opinion that it's too early for them to reveal themselves. I'd rather they don't.
avatar
trentonlf: If someone has information like that they should always share it. What happens if they don't share it and are killed at night or by a vigilante? Whatever knowledge they had dies with them. If someone believes they have found scum they should always come forth IMO.
The start of the day is too early. They are not going to killed till the day is over so why not wait? What if the blocked player gets lynched naturally and they don't have to reveal themselves? What if during the course of the day they get more info to confirm that the person they blocked is actually scum?

Besides, even if they 100% sure know they blocked scum, everyone would just vote the scum. It's true the scum will get lynched, but come tomorrow we again have no wagons to analyse.

And imagine an even worse situation. A blocker reveals themselves, we immediately lynch their target who happens to be innocent (the NK was blocked by a bus-driver, doctor or whatever). This way we lost an innocent, revealed a blocker and on top of that have no wagon to analyse.

The day is young. Plenty of time to come out later.
avatar
supplementscene: You're still upset about me correcting your grammar aren't you?
avatar
trentonlf: Your whole attitude gets under my skin. The less I have to talk with you or interact with you the better. So unless you have some in game related question of me just leave me alone and I'll leave you alone.
So you're saying the friend request you sent me after you said you wanted to kill me was an accident then?
avatar
supplementscene: So you're saying the friend request you sent me after you said you wanted to kill me was an accident then?
What??? I never sent you a friend request. I blocked you in chat, and never once have I threatened to kill you. In game i said if I had the ability to kill you I would, and that still stands. Not sure exactly what you are trying to start here but whatever it is please stop.
avatar
PookaMustard: And ZFR for immediately jumping on lynching me because of my jumping on the early scene wagon, which wouldn't have been a successful wagon to be honest.
avatar
ZFR: Interesting. I wasn't on your table yesterday. Why the change of heart?
My mind's in a scatter and GOG actually didn't let the initial version of this post through, great.

You actually were on the table. Just lower priority to SirPrimalform and Fran, who were then my top suspects for lurking.
Check post 190 in full. Can't quote myself here for some reason.
avatar
supplementscene: So you're saying the friend request you sent me after you said you wanted to kill me was an accident then?
avatar
trentonlf: What??? I never sent you a friend request. I blocked you in chat, and never once have I threatened to kill you. In game i said if I had the ability to kill you I would, and that still stands. Not sure exactly what you are trying to start here but whatever it is please stop.
No you did actually send me a friend request. I rejected it so I can't prove it now. You must have clicked 'Add Friend' in your attempts to block. Or perhaps you wanted to be friends with the sympathetic poster and accidently clicked me? I can only speculate.
Can we please try to be a bit more civilised?

The unpleasantness is getting distressing.

If you have serious grievances, PM me and I can do what I can to mediate.
avatar
JoeSapphire: Can we please try to be a bit more civilised?

The unpleasantness is getting distressing.

If you have serious grievances, PM me and I can do what I can to mediate.
No grievances from me, I’ve continually asked Scene to keep the talk to just in game but he’s persistent on not doing so. I don’t want any issues or problems so if he keeps addressesing me on matters out of game I’ll just ignore him.