Online for a few minutes and trying to catch up. This may have to be several small posts.
For RWarehall, I see absolutely nothing that could sway me from making him the Day 1 lynch, and it seems this is well understood by everyone.
I would like to say I appreciate very much the participation, humor, and grace he's bringing to the role. :) Very well played, and as I always view the true goal of playing this game to have fun, he's certainly been adding to the fun factor. Thumbs up from me, mate! That said,
Vote RWarehall Since we get to continue talking at night and all.
The big news is, of course CSPVG and his amaaaaaazing coincidence that
he is the town cop, and investigated me night zero.
Others have expressed already most of my thoughts on this. If town, it's a very inconveniently-timed reveal.
I do think it's worth noting that one of the "hot" topics of conversation the last couple of Mafia games has been how much mass role-claims can damage the game and make it too easy for Town to win. If you were a veteran mod, advised by other veteran mods, what would you do to counteract this strategy? Two cops? Could be.
I would believe in two sane town cops long before I believed that both of us are town cops, but paranoid or insane. This game may be crazy, but I doubt it's bastard.
Far more likely is scum bluff intended to confuse the newbie or the outright gullible. (I won't mention names there, *cough* ADALIA *cough*) We'll probably have to hack this out in Day 2 once the NK and other actions resolve. I do sort of resent the fact that I'm basically forced to use my night 1 investigation on CSPVG now, though. I still find it highly likely I'm killed tonight (But catching the serial killer Day 1? Totally worth it.) and won't be able to report my findings... but yep, I don't see any real choice about who I investigate now. I would have much preferred to investigate the missing player
(HINT HINT - WHERE'S THE PINEAPPLE ALREADY?) It's almost too much to deal with right now. I think we're at the place where we can finish off Day 1, keep chatting at night, and once all the night actions are resolved figure out what to do with CSPVG. I hope I'm around for it, but if not, I'll still have fun in the observer thread. :)
btw, I still think sitting on my character name is a good idea. If I survive in Day 2, I can see it being more useful to reveal at that point. Especially as I
strongly dislike CSPVG's
character name.