Still you should have reasons for your reads. I know it's D1 and all, but your statement about GR, Pooka, Joe was quite strong. So, where does this conviction come from so early on D1?

You were right. I don't like it but I've come to expect such kind of logical chains from you so meh.


I fear I've started to lose the ability to detect sarcasm and subtle jokes over the internet. Is that supposed to be it or are you serious?

No, me having a face palm moment. I was looking at that as if trent was a player. Forgot he was hosting.

As a side note, it wasn't "strong". I've written this in previous games already, barring a kalunga-type slip on D1 we have little info, so all "reads" on D1 are going to be weak. When I write "I think/read X is scum/town" on D1 I never mean it as a strong read; there is just a small indication or even a gut feeling that I'm happy to go with till we get better info.

That said, in this particular instance, my read on GR might be a bit strongish. I think we all saw what he did? I've only seen it once before in a game when he was Town.

Pooka - I liked the way he tried to get us out of RVS. I don't think scum Pooka would want to draw the attention, though he's experience enough by now to do it for the WIFOM.

Joe - I liked his reaction and town reading of Pooka.

In addition to the above, I'm wondering if I should (weakly!) scum!read catte based on his "Pooka is rolefishing" post? But the "obvs" in that post makes me think he was just making a joke, so that is not really enough to make me vote someone who was Lynched D1 last game.

Well, he kind of made sure we did :) This is the first time I see it to my recollection. When did he did that as Town?

Harry Potter.

I keep hearing about that game, maybe I should allocate some time to take a look at it. I most likely won't but it be a lot cooler if I did.
Anyway, how did that go for him and the Town back then? Is it a reliable indication now?

...yep, I don't.

So as ZFR said, I'm experienced enough to do this as a wolf. "Pooka starts the day attracting attention to himself and trying to get us out of RVS? Probably likely to be Town!" sounds like music to my Mafia ears, not gonna lie.

But then you show up and tell us that Trent wouldn't tell me that if I was Mafia. I...don't buy it, to be honest. It's just farfetched. I see trent in an alternate universe where I am Mafia (something I would also say in that alternate universe BTW) saying that just as well. "POOKS REMEMBER YOUR VOTE SO YOU DON'T EVER MESS UP YOUR VOTING." If not for me then for the others who were gonna talk about how awkward the voting mechanism is. He just mentioned me because I was super vocal about it, which seems more likely than telling me because I am more likely to be Town.

----
So from the way we're having it, Joe would block Lift (or Vitek). The other two abstained from answering. While I don't like the line of reason for Joe to townread me, I do like him answering my question right away, unsure how to feel about those who didn't for now. Something bothered me about SPCatte framing my question as "rolefishing," though.

Jokes aside, I truly was curious about why you picked such choices.
(Saw your answers later on to another user, so no need to repeat them btw)

------------------------

Bill goes over to where he had placed a boombox, smacks the side, and a toon begins to play
(It is post 2 in the link above)

"Now that...that takes me back....all them sponsors"

Yeah, yeah we all did...
>_>
<_<
...
...
...
Oh, I see.

How many times he hasn't done it as town and how many times he hasn't done it as mafia?

A-HA! So you DO have Mafia ears! Nice of you to admit it. ;-) The question now is, do you have them on your belt as trophies? Or are they attached to your head, because you are Mafia?

But I'm totally with you there. I think scum-Pook would do such a stunt to get out of RVS and start steering the game.

So let me ask you back. You already asked about three roles. Let me ask you about another one: if you were a Vig, whom would you kill? And why?

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
RP:

Oh dearest Lola. Let's go somewhere quiet and I will explain to you what's going on. All privately-like, you know? *wink* <3

It's Wile E. Coyote, thank you.

What bothered you about it? I certainly get why he would frame it as such.
After all, you started to talk about roles and night actions.

Suspicion is good.....even of me.....I award thee 1 extra town point.
(Points have no value beyond the game and cannot be traded in for anything else.....and can be added to or retracted at any time. Restrictions may apply....results may vary. Do not use on sensitive skin)

If he'd said "just try to remember who you're voting for so you don't mess up"

then I wouldn't have thought anything of it.

BUT

he didn't.

He said "It shouldn’t be hard to remember who you are voting for and why"

now OBVIOUSLY I'm not going to be jumping off any cliffs because I trust this reasoning so much, but it's enough to give you a lean.