What information did I give away? What I said is basic mafia game play strategy, and likely known by those on all sides.

Also it's not like i'm asking or want any said investigative role(if we have one) to say such....if you might be trying to insinuate that.

So far you've implied you have a PR, but you're not the cop.

I had something in mind but I was likely wrong and I'll leave you alone now.

But apparently you don't feel like leaving yourself alone :D Anyway, I'm done.


Day-chat?

There's many other PRs....it doesn't exactly narrow it down for them that much.

Sidenote: Tbh at this point I don't think scum would go after such low hanging fruit(as ZFR sort of hinted in Post # 103) and expose themselves so much.....so I will lean you slightly town for the time being.
(Hopefully that won't bite me in the gluteus maximus later)

But for that to happen we'd need the cop to be a moronic moron.

Read what nmillar wrote. Pooka's hypothetical discussions are something, but real role discussions are just bad.

Yes. Which part confuses you? "Day"? "Chat"?

Halve? Are we certain the scum are two people?

Yes we are. 3 vs 7 means that a Day 1 mislynch puts us at MYLO on D2. Not something a host would do.
2 vs 1 vs 7 is possible (with 1 being either a neutral or scum), but regardless, any scum "team" is made up of 2 people.

I really don't like this question of dedo. Has a subtle "hey, I don't know how many people the Mafia team has because I'm not Mafia" LAMIST feel to it.

While claiming or when it comes to it in otehr natural way. You brought it up while it was not necessary. It's not the same thing.

Don't you think there is chance talking about PR's could lead to some conjectures about roles from people reactions and then be used by mafia to possibly make correct assumptions? I do and that's why I find it at least slightly bordrering fishing territory.
Also you never know what will make someone claim PR with no reason. Right, GH?
What if one was to answer you who would they target and later someone would claim exactly the same course of actions happened. I feel like it would add unnecessary layer of confusion to the situation.


Awwww, how can reliance on the other anti-town party's NK backfire sometimes. Lovely.
So he crumbed the same way but with some results, not just for the sake of it.

How so? If we have one and they investigated me and found me to be town, they could keep their mouths shut, keeping them safe. If i'm scum, they'd out me and likely the game would be handed to town. Or is there something wrong with my reasoning that i'm missing?

(Note I already know they'd have to waste a "shot" on me to do so)

I wasn't asking anyone to state their roles or poking for roles, though.

I just have a non-standard method of play. Love it or not, it's just how it is.

And your "this and that is/would be bad town play" posts don't? ;)

Non-standard is not the word that comes to mind as first.

If they have investigated you in the first place, they're a moronic moron. QED.

Without counting Russian Roulette the last game was the only one for a long time (to my recollection) where the scum had a day-chat. I always thought that was sort of an "exotic" feature so any time some brings it up it tingles me.


Fair point but it's a role madness so it's perfectly possible this is balanced out somehow so I wouldn't just throw away the possibility of 3 scum based on just player numbers.

You seem to be certain he is town if you think it's something to be resolved by mafia team.

Yes, I had a "good" PR that time and wanted to play it right and put in some more effort than usual. It paid off somewhat.

----------------

And what if I was scum and that would help town win? Or do you not care about winning?

Or.....

You seem to be hinting that it'd be a waste to investigate me(by any potential investigative role), as if you already know I am town.

Scum!ZFR trying to dissuade any potential investigative PRs from clearing me(so I remain a distraction to some) perhaps?

It was in fact in 64, 65, 67. And this is 68.

Anyway, I was making a hypothetical scenrio where GR was being coached. The only possibility of this happening is day-chat or N0 chat. The latter of which is far less common.

No "certain", but yes I think him likely Town. However, I didn't mean resolved by Mafia, but that it will self-resolve. It's same as the Carradice-claim last game, if he's alive, he'll be under more scrutiny, but Mafia are taking a risk letting him live.