Are you referring to your scum-chat :)


Sounds lovely.

Did you not answer my question intentionally?


Just remember that you're fine until you look down. That's what gets you.

Oh, are you talking about him being a sPoRtsman? To be honest, it's not that high of a bar...in a game explicitly advertised as Role Madness.

You make them sound like cat ears. Can I have Mafia Cat ears?

Based on D1 information alone? I'd say Vitek. Not getting 100% good vibes from him. That said, it would be foolish to shoot anyone this early, and I'd rather be more careful about my vig shots because of...well, you know. Save shoots when it will give you an advantage over Mafia and when they won't end the Day.

What do you mean?

This:

So you noticed that "typo" but not the more obvious on...err, I mean nothing to see here. *whistles*

(Also an aside: role madness doesn't mean everyone would be PRs, afaik....so anyone with PRs would still be somewhat important, though I guess not as much so as if a game is a "normal" style game)

Wooops, sorry. I completely missed the fact that you asked a question in your post.

To summarize: both Mafia and SK-JOAT role-copped him N1 and identified him as cop. He threw obvious bReadCRumBs D2 about the Townie he investigated. And still, both SK and Mafia decide not to kill him N2. Which backfired badly because same Night he identified a Mafia. He was protected N3, and finally killed successfully N4.

Of course someone would talk about roles and night actions in a Role Madness game. It was only a matter of time.

Besides, I'm still not sure why he would even frame it like that. Rolefishing is attempting to know what role he has so that mafia could make an informed night kill decision. Giving him the burden of a random role doesn't help Mafia make a good call.

Thanks!


Why do you feel the need to mention said importance?

I quickly skimmed through your posts in the morning and that was all I saw. Granted...I wasn't exactly paying too much attention by then. Anyway, yes, you have a point, role madness doesn't necessitate everyone being a PR, but...it wouldn't be role madness without a lot of PRs, right? So crumbing PR is actually not that massive of a deal. You could've done it as scum.

Maybe because if I have a PR it is very important? Why else would I bother?

I get killed off during the night or day in most games anyways..... so maybe I want to help my team win, or maybe I just want to enjoy the theme and flavor a bit more...or maybe a bit of both?

Of course if you want to suspect me go right ahead....that is also acceptable.

Agreed. Seems a bit of an obvious ploy to use the same gambit as he did in another game where he played as town, and knows full well that there are some players here that also featured in that game, and could come to the conclusion, "Oh, he was town then when he did it, so he must be town now."

Unvote Pookina

This just seems you're trying to push your own importance following your bread-crumbing. which was about as subtle as a hand grenade in a barrel of oat meal.

Ok, I didn't want to have to shame myself like this and admit it, but......lean a bit closer...little closer: I have piss poor memory and forgot it was role madness until I just found out.

Yeah, it makes me seem like even more of a "weakest link" type player...but eh can't make me look worse as a player than I already do(on average).

------------------------

You give me too much credit....I can barely remember who said what without notes, and often times my good moves come down to luck.

But suspect as you will, vote as you will......I will just say this: If I am reading mafia wiki right, my role is a decent boon to my team...but if you want to help remove that boon then who am I to stop you?

Perhaps, but I never was one to be able to figure out how to crumb really subtly, so I don't bother and do it as best I can.

Also tbf it's much more subtle when compared to prior "crumbed" games.

(Also also read the reply above to Pooka)

You died at night only once.

I'd completely agree had it been anyone else. But don't let the new nick fool you - it's still GR.

Sorry.

Of course, there is always the possibility that fellow Mafia day-chat coached him to do it.
But it's still too much of a gamble drawing too much attention to your only scumbuddy.

Regardless, best way to deal with it is let it resolve at Night. Let the "super important" PR be scum's problem. And it will be super-hilarious if they decide not to kill him and the breadloafcrumbs-GR exposes a Mafia member again.

My statement still holds true, though. And yeah, most likely i'm not as as big of a threat to scum, so they let town do the work for them.

Or maybe I am the le evil mastermind behind it all.....mwahahahaha....ha?

Ok, i'm not, and not that good a player....but one can dream(of being a better player I mean).

No probs

If we have a cop they could investigate me.....that way if I was scum(totally not tho) town could lynch me, and if I was town I wouldn't be a distraction.

Of course that would likely expose such a role if they had to out me....but it'd be worth it if i were scum to lose one town player and then halve(?) the scum team.

If you're town, please stop giving away information to the mafia.