This is the best premium module I've tried so far. It gave me a full pirate experience, with treasure maps, survival on a desert island, and evil powers lurking underneath the sea. Maybe the Undersea part could have been developed more, but the plot itself was more interesting than in some of the highest praised modules. Haven't encountered any bugs, maybe aside from evil pirate overlord having too low persuasion check - but maybe he just likes half-orc ladies who can hit hard. If you want something fun to spend one or two evenings, try it out. It's really worth its price.
4.5* rounded up because I had so much more fun than I expected from a free game. . Every scene has so many amazing details I was as interested in taking it all in as I was in progressing the story. The ambient sounds, music and narrator's voice made the immersion into the story almost complete. It's not without issues: on my screen the tinypointer pixel was almost invisible at times, and thank creators for subtitles, because there were few screens where the narration disappeared in the background music, but none of that ruined my fun. Even though we're railroaded through the story, the trivia hunt keeps the player engaged. I first got my hands on Lovecraft's stories in middle school, and the team still managed to find some trivia that would be new to me. And it's all for free!
