Posted on: December 11, 2024

xerxespersrex

Jeux: 245 Avis: 2

Excellent game, but a little unstable

I've been playing this game since I was a small child. It was one of the first PC games I installed on my own computer from CD-ROM, and I played countless hours upon hours against the computer, and even some games online in the 2010's using various third-party online clients. I think the fantasy setting, the asymmetrical gameplay, and the beautiful graphics are all amazing and stand out for its time. The gameplay feels crisp, and there's lots of varieties to the units and races. The expansion pack is included here, adding a fifth race to all game modes and a new fun campaign to play. There's also a map maker included in the install directory (Cartographer) which lets you make custom maps for multiplayer rather easily and quickly. The game does have its faults, however. The controls are a little counterintuitive compared to giants in the field like StarCraft for example, and there are situations where the asymmetrical gameplay makes some races highly, highly favored over others depending on the map layout. For example, playing Aramon on an island map is torture, since you have very few units that can effectively cross water or do battle not tethered to walkable land in general. My main gripe has been my gripe with the game for the past 20 years: it's pretty unstable. Alt-tabbing out of the window, or even pressing the wrong button on the multiplayer screen, will freeze the game or crash it to desktop. Ironically, the older Total Annihilation is more stable on modern computers than TA:K is. This isn't GOG's fault at all, though I wish that this game, or at least Total Annihilation, would be adopted by the Good Old Game preservation efforts to keep the games stable on modern computers. Overall, I think for the price this game is sold at on here, it's a great game to pick up. Just make sure when you sit down to play that you're prepared to play for a long while without alt tabbing, or to save very often, as there will be crashes at some point while playing.

Trouvez-vous ce commentaire utile ?

Posted on: May 7, 2011

Arachnyd

Possesseur vérifié

Jeux: 28 Avis: 2

Much maligned but highly enjoyable

The basic premise was to take the highly successful Total Annihilation as a base and create a fantasy RTS the operates on similar principles. The result was a game that received mixed reviews from critics, but this was one of the most enjoyable entries in the RTS genre. Lest we forget, Cavedog gave us DLC before DLC was cool (or profitable). Many will argue that the game is flawed because it lacked the same kind of balance you find in games like the Age of Empires series in which every unit has a weakness countered by another unit. But that was hardly the point of Total Annihilation. It was all about amassing resources to build a huge army and decimate your enemies. They didn't call it Total Annihilation for nothing. This is a company that recognized that games should just be plain fun to play, and the entries in the Total Annihilation series fit the bill. Kingdoms filled a niche and provided some delicious and unique RTS fun.

Trouvez-vous ce commentaire utile ?

Posted on: January 9, 2012

Charon121

Possesseur vérifié

Jeux: 332 Avis: 24

Very underappreciated

[WARNING: some spoilers in the review!] Other people have described the game, so I'm going to write about the thing that impressed me the most about the game -- its storytelling. Great narration and hand-painted scenes with added effects between the missions create immersion like no other game. You'll itch to complete the missions as soon as possible just to find out what happens next. There's intrepid exploration, valiant defense, monstrous attacks, prison breaks, twists that turn the tide of battle, and wondrous sorcery. In one mission you'll make the landfall in the jungle as Veruna, in the next you'll take up the mantle of a Zhon shaman to drive away the Verunan invaders. In another instance you'll conquer a suspiciously empty Tarosian city, only to butcher them mercilessly in the next mission as Taros. It is a grand tale of epic fantasy. Too bad the gameplay mechanics are somewhat clumsy.

Trouvez-vous ce commentaire utile ?

Posted on: December 16, 2011

idontdothis

Possesseur vérifié

Jeux: 12 Avis: 1

Beautiful, unusually compelling game with risky design.

My god, this game! The years I spent obsessed with this game! I found Blarg's explanation that TA's lead artist took the helm as project lead on this one insightful and i explains a lot of what I already know. Let me get down to it: I love this game. The story line and art is as compelling as some of the best fantasy books. It's deeply unusual, it takes risks, it has tremendous depth and a fascinating amount of design detail has been embedded in it. The criticism that balance and game mechanics could be better has a point. It's biggest problem was that when it was made there almost wasn't a computer in existence that could run it; clearly a problem no longer! It's still a lot of fun to play though! One of the most interesting mechanics to play with (that I don't see often reported on) is that individual units are able to level up. Your bread and butter units such as swordmen and archers, should they live long enough and get enough kills will gain significant health pool, damage and regen benefits (at least x3 from memory.) At the top of each technology tree is a super expensive dragon unit. These in particular benefit hugely from levelling up. Their initial strength to cost ratio is rather dismal but over time can become rather impressive. Units at max level develop visible gold plating on their skin or armour. Each race has prominent and unique abilities and strengths with very little overlap. This is a very pure game. Almost no concession has been made in design to balance or competition. You get the sense the designer wasn't going for that. I think this was someone's baby. For all the focus on art, mythology and high-minded design and the lack of concession to the realities of interactivity it's an incredibly fun and compelling game to play if you play it the right way. It's not about finding the right counter strat. Almost every fight can be won with a defensive tower creep and aerial scouts. The best way to play it is like a cat playing with a mouse: you know you could win at any moment but it's about testing the flexibility of the system and basking in the sensory overload. I'd particularly recommend this game to any aspiring game artists. It had a huge influence on me.

Trouvez-vous ce commentaire utile ?

Posted on: September 19, 2018

Vamrem

Possesseur vérifié

Jeux: 193 Avis: 6

Still playing as if hours were minutes

Still playing this particular RTS from time to time since the 2000’s, with its remarkable physics system, which I remember was innovative for its time (and still pretty advanced today!), but I enjoy particularly its soft RPG feature, making units gain ranks in small groups while I hold a fort, until all my army gets gold. For the bad, its worst downside are the unbalanced dragon, and especially the deity (which is insanely powerful, practically wins by its own), but you can banish unit types in the map editor (making an extra challenge to leave the opposite faction with their dragon for example!), you decide.

Trouvez-vous ce commentaire utile ?

Découvrez les jeux de CD PROJEKT RED

Ne manquez pas

Featured

Proche, mais pas une correspondance exacte

Total Annihilation: Kingdoms + Iron Plague

Autres notes

Ajouter un avis

Modifier un avis

Supprimer cet avis ?

Signaler cet avis

Informations complémentaires (obligatoire) :

Signaler cet avis