Tarm: I bought Privateer 2, installed it, played the first "mission", promptly uninstalled it and never looked back.
I hated the atmosphere, graphics, combat and it didn't even feel like I was in the WC universe.
But many say it's wonderful so what do I know?
Privateer 2 is one of my all time favorites, it's dark, moody and everyone is out to frell you up. Also interesting to note that it wasn't for a decade that I saw Clive Owen in a film after privateer 2, and he had become the go to guy for a large number of pictures. I don't believe it was supposed to be in the WC universe, as it was just "Privateer 2: The Darkening", not "Wing Commander: Privateer 2".
The wide array of ships, weapons and the storyline while quite cliche today (and in movies for a while) was great.