tfishell: Bump b/c of new people; I'm still interested in these stories. :)
Mivas: I realized you didn't share yours :P. Or was it Beneath the Steel Sky?
I didn't think anyone cared about mine, lol.
I discovered the world of
Beyond Good and Evil here, pretty darn magical in a way. Gorgeous music of course. (I got to the final boss, but never truly finished the game.)
Little Big Adventure 2 was another "magical" game that I've never completed, but I really enjoyed the imaginative atmosphere.
Unreal Gold - with its towering landscapes, intriguing story and stunning soundtrack - pulled me in. I actually finished this one, despite getting stuck on some of the button puzzles a few times.
Postal 2 is definitely not for everyone, but I already had fantastic memories about imagining what one could do in this game from years back. I played the demo to death, and when I finally picked up the game, it turned out to be more than just a gore fest. You could play how you wanted to - run around, search for secrets, enjoy the colorful or sometimes surprisingly lush scenery. Unlocking new areas felt like rewards for completing the missions, and Postal Dude's voice combined with the sarcastic spoken dialogue parodying the American Way was great. The world was much smaller than GTA, but it paid attention to detail.
Serious Sam:Second Encounter was a great shooter that just kept getting crazier and crazier. The humor often made me chuckle, too. I actually had to use cheats on the final boss, but I've actually finished this whereas I have yet to finish Serious Sam 2.
Duke Nukem: Manhattan Project is a platformer I actually really enjoyed. It's been quite some time, but the running, gunning, and jumping worked well together.
Beneath a Steel Sky is an adventure game I enjoyed for the characters, dialogue, and music. In some games of the genre, the people populating the area feel so strange or out of place, but the main character felt like a normal guy, his snarky robot was likable, the fat guy was a jerk but had the personality you expected, etc.