I would hope no one would make the mistake of counter claiming the doctor role.

However, I'm also really surprised at you Sage1234. Why would you make such a claim with so little pressure?

Both yours and Trent's recent comments strike me as a bit of flailing about.

There was no finger pointing, just offering sympathy to mrkgnao who felt guilty for what happened. All we did was point out that he was not the only one who mentioned lyncher and not to feel guilty for what happened as it seemed inevitable the way HijacK was acting.

Because things tend to heat up once I go to sleep for the night and I will not have the same crap happening this game. I will be killed off and I am ok with that as long as it helps the town. If I was lynched before i could state my peace it would be bad for the town and good for the scum.

Let's discuss lynching/killing the doctor is good for the town.

So, Sage claimed town doctor. Anyone wishes to also claim town doctor?

trentonlf, CSPVG, budejovice, QuadrAlien - I would appreciate your insight about why Robbeasy was targetted by the scum.

Just want to state Sage's post #424 seems like scum slip in my opinion.

Wifey just home from work, so off to have conversation (read that as listen and say nothing).

As I said in post 387 I'm not sure how the scum knew to target Robb. It had to just be luck that they picked him.

I have to beg everyone's forgiveness once more. 3 hours sleep, 12 hours of stress, haven't eaten since breakfast. Any analysis is just going to be me talking without a lot of coherent, or at least meaningful, thought behind it. I am hammered, and not in the good way. But the IRS has accepted all of the returns I released via efile! On the plus side, the managing partner is taking the day off tomorrow and things should be slow. So much has been posted just since this morning, I can't even go home and crash... taking a printout of today's proceedings.

I haven't lamented the lynch yet. I still don't understand the opening play of our loving duo. Hijack was b-to-the-wall but I'm a bit puzzled how JMich wasn't able to rein it in to any degree. A blow, but to mangle a few cliches, I guess it's all milk under the bridge at this point.

I don't have any idea about the Robb NK. Is adalia correct about a scan coming at the end of Night. I saw a mention somewhere on the wiki of Night 0 - is there any chance there was an early scan? There were mentions of Robb from flubb and afterwards, including me dubbing it the "like" post. Perhaps there's some connection regarding those posts in their thought processes leading to the nk? Dumb luck (or bad luck, as stated, given dedo's action)?

After today's posts sage, trent, and CSP certainly deserve more attention. But I'm probably just reacting to what everyone else has said, so again, I'm going to bid adieu and will spend my first hour at work tomrrow catching up on what happens between now and then.

I didn't mean how they "knew" he was a cop, if they knew. I meant why they picked him, assuming they didn't "know" he was a cop.

I'm not sure why he would have been the one targeted by the scum, he did not seem to have posted or done anything to make him a target. I would have thought the scum would have picked someone who was known town by everyone. I mean Robb was on most peoples radar as a little scummy, so not sure what the reasoning would be to target him at night. I guess the scum just took a shot in the dark and got lucky.

Now we need to find a scum and lynch him today. With all this role claiming going on it makes it easier if it is all true. There are 9 of us left, with 5 of us being town that leaves 4 people to look at who could be scum. I am guessing 2 or 3 are scum out of CSPVG, Quadralien, budejovice, and adaliabooks.
1. CSPVG: : He has not really done anything to throw off a scum vibe other than lurking and the one post directly after Krypsyn nudged him, making it look like he was there the whole time but trying to hide. As adailabooks pointed out his lurking could be what made the night phase so long.

2. Quadralien: He has also not really done anything to put off a scum vibe except for lurking, even more than CSPVG. He did say real life would make his posting erratic. Again, as adailabooks pointed out this could be why the night phase was so long.

3. budejovice: Tries to be active since real life has kept him busy too. The only thing I could find that jumped out was he pushed thebwagon after I voted HijacK.

4. adaliabooks: He keeps changing his mind as to who is scummy. Before the lynch it was Robb and CSPVG. After the night phase it is me and Sage. He even made up an lie about me saying " And last but not least, as soon as I called him out I'm suddenly his chief suspect for being scum. Which is a little overly defensive for my liking." Yeah, that never happened. Do I think he is being scummy now, for sure.

If we are to believe dedoporno and Sage about their role claims we have a 75% chance to lynch a scum today. I can't see dedo lying about the NK of Robb, it would be a bad move on his part to claim he was a vigilante. I also tend to believe Sage as she has not done anything that I found scummy. She seemed to have only revealed her role in defense to her being accused of being scum, and again I can't see her lying about it as that would be a bad move on her part.

@dedoporno, what do you make of this post from CSPVG???

Right, I don't believe Sage's role claim. Her post is incredibly inconsistent. Her list states dedo and robb as possible scum, despite one being dead and confirmed town and the other being accepted as 90% town (even by Sage herself). She also seems to think trent was going to get the NK and she saved him. Whereas it seems obvious dedo's analysis of the morning post is correct and both he and the scum targeted Robb.

As far as me lying about trent, that was actually a mix up. It was Sage who pinned me as her prime subject, trent just had me on his list.

I did point the finger at both Robb and CSPVG, as Robb's behaviour seemed a little off and so did CSPVG. I still have CSPVG as my top pick for the last scum, just that trent and sage are higher on my list now.

And finally, I would also role claim, but I have no evidence to back it up and it will get me NK'd. Make of that what you will.

No more claiming please.

At this point it seems mafia have all the information (as well as the kills) and we are grasping as shadows.

And the amount of lurking in this thread is too damn high<insert meme here>

I'm in big meeting right now, I'll be able to post a couple of hours later. Just a little FYI.

Some people just don't know how to prioritize.....