StarChan: If you enjoyed both those shows, you might like Stargate Universe, which is where they both meet, after a fashion. It is really well written and has a fascinating premise.
This one I haven't seen yet, unfortunately it's one of those shows that got canceled before they finished it. Will have to try.
Telika: And if you tolerate anime, there's
Cowboy Bebop. The series and the film (which should be watched either after the series, or before the last couple of episodes). It's pretty wonderful, actually. And this comes from someone who dislikes animes in general.
Aaaaand
of course of course... I hear a lot of good stuff about Cowboy Bebop, so this is one that's on my list. As for the UFO one... THAT reminds of me of No One Lives Forever, haha. I've never heard of that show, but looks as though it would be entertaining like the original BSG.
StarChan: And then there is good old Babylon 5 from the 1990's. Production values are as you might expect for such an old show, but the scope and the storytelling are .. um .. out of this world.
Babylon 5 was awesome. I didn't care much for Sheridan when he first came on, but he grew on me. I couldn't watch it when the new commander after him took over. The show kind of lost its spark with me. Same with the Ranger spin off.
XYCat: You're looking for Lexx :D
That's the one with the insect looking starship in the first episode isn't it? The last person in that battle at the beginning, the shadowy bad guy recreates? I've been looking for the name of that show. I saw that episode years ago and wanted to continue it.
LootHunter: Since people here already suggested good space sci-fi (and yes, Babylon 5 has the best story and most well-crafterd lore), I would name a few good anime similar to Blue:
Neon Genesis Evangelion (I suggest TV-series, not OVA)
Tekkaman Blade (the one released in 92-93)
And Robotech/Macross - that's classics.
Grew up on Robotech, and I the first generation was always one of my favorite storylines.
Farscape, Firefly, even the campy Andromeda I enjoyed. So many options to pick from, thank you fellow GOGgers! I now have a new list to go thru with all the suggestions :)