Logic have no place in the old Amiga vs Atari quarrel.
I never understood the hostility.
If I didn't have an Amiga I would have bough an Atari ST instead.
For me the Atari ST was like the slightly handicapped little brother, and the real enemy was the Japanese consoles.
What alienated me a bit from the Amiga community was the blatant fanboyism. A game like Black Crypt was considered far superior to Dungeon Master and Chaos Strikes Back, because it was an Amiga exclusive and DM and CBS were ST games.
Also the delusions and self denial that was comical. It was obvious that the Amiga was doomed by 1992, yet the fanbois held on to their ancient beliefs and refused to face the truth that the future of gaming (beyond the kiddie stuff made for consoles) lay in the PC.