It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Fancy dice are great .... in theory. In practice, it's a bit hit-and-miss. The mage dice OP linked, I personally think look neat but wouldn't take chances playing with them; on the other hand, I bought a box of fancy Call of Cthulhu dice recently (these ones, to be precise) and despite their design, they work perfectly well when playing, they're easily legible in ok light (if you're playing in darkness, well, there is a glow-in-the-dark version of them :D).

Unless I could test these mage dice in a shop and see how they work, I wouldn't buy them. Supposedly they're designed to give the same rolls as their more conventional siblings, but if you have enough stuff on your table (like snacks, drinks, books, etc) they're probably a lot more likely to simply roll off and disappear beneath a sofa. Happens frequently enough with normal dice, and losing one of these expensive things to that? Bitter.
Post edited August 24, 2016 by Moon-and-Star
avatar
Moon-and-Star: Fancy dice are great .... in theory. In practice, it's a bit hit-and-miss. The mage dice OP linked, I personally think look neat but wouldn't take chances playing with them; on the other hand, I bought a box of fancy Call of Cthulhu dice recently (these ones, to be precise) and despite their design, they work perfectly well when playing, they're easily legible in ok light (if you're playing in darkness, well, there is a glow-in-the-dark version of them :D).

Unless I could test these mage dice in a shop and see how they work, I wouldn't buy them. Supposedly they're designed to give the same rolls as their more conventional siblings, but if you have enough stuff on your table (like snacks, drinks, books, etc) they're probably a lot more likely to simply roll off and disappear beneath a sofa. Happens frequently enough with normal dice, and losing one of these expensive things to that? Bitter.
Has Cthulhu gone back to a percentile skill system now?

I agree with the OP, they're pretty, but I'd use something clearer.
avatar
Breja: I mean look at this. I mean sure, they look great as decoration, but for actually playing? And those aren't even the worst. What I really despise is sme ornate, barely readable shit like this. Orthis. It might look ok on a photo, but trust me- when playing the game, sitting across the table, in less than "perfect for photo" light? You end up with everyone leaning over this side and that, trying to see what did that show off fucker just roll. I can get collecting them- if you've got the money, honey, buy whatever you want. Hell, if I was crazy rich I might collect such stuff myself. But actually using that? When I'm the DM you either roll dice that I can easily read, or GTFO.
Back in my DM times I might have plainly forbid the use of the transparent dice and maybe also (after testing) all but the d20 from the wizard dice. The d20 I would have claimed for the evening as DM right and bribe for my good will :D
avatar
Moon-and-Star: Fancy dice are great .... in theory. In practice, it's a bit hit-and-miss. The mage dice OP linked, I personally think look neat but wouldn't take chances playing with them; on the other hand, I bought a box of fancy Call of Cthulhu dice recently (these ones, to be precise) and despite their design, they work perfectly well when playing, they're easily legible in ok light (if you're playing in darkness, well, there is a glow-in-the-dark version of them :D).

Unless I could test these mage dice in a shop and see how they work, I wouldn't buy them. Supposedly they're designed to give the same rolls as their more conventional siblings, but if you have enough stuff on your table (like snacks, drinks, books, etc) they're probably a lot more likely to simply roll off and disappear beneath a sofa. Happens frequently enough with normal dice, and losing one of these expensive things to that? Bitter.
avatar
mechmouse: Has Cthulhu gone back to a percentile skill system now?

I agree with the OP, they're pretty, but I'd use something clearer.
Yep, the version my group plays is based on percentages (e.g. you have 50% in a skill, you need to roll below 51% to succeed on a skill check). As far as I know we are playing the most recent version of the game - but since our GM has a Polish core book, which I can't understand, I can't say that for certain.
Post edited August 24, 2016 by Moon-and-Star
So many cool looking dice here. All mine are so plain and boring.
avatar
Breja: I mean look at this. I mean sure, they look great as decoration, but for actually playing?
These are... strange indeed. And I don't remember that things like that were used 25 years ago when I regularly played half a dozen different p&ps (GM'd MERP and the then version of Star Wars and played Shadowrun, Cyberpunk 2020, Runequest, KULT, Harnmaster and a crazy German p&p named "Call of the Warlock").

I do love my "Mutant: Year Zero" dice though! Practical, excellent legibility, reduced fanciness and zero imbalance problems.

When I backed the "Coriolis" Kickstarter last month, I was actually quite happy the system didn't throw any special dice at you. Backers, of course, immediately went out of their way to procure and advertise spacey-fancy dice that cost a billion.

Not sure that's what p&ps are about. :)
Post edited August 24, 2016 by Vainamoinen
avatar
Breja: I mean look at this.
Are those dice, or tops? The majority of them look like I should put the point on the table and spin it.
avatar
Breja: ...
actually that dices look like sex toys, so you can use them in role playing "games"
avatar
Breja: I mean look at this.
avatar
Bookwyrm627: Are those dice, or tops? The majority of them look like I should put the point on the table and spin it.
What really gets me is the "2-sided spell book die". You cant spin that. Or roll. Or do anything with it.
avatar
Breja: What I really despise is sme ornate, barely readable shit like this.
Those dice are gorgeous! Does anyone know where I could buy a set?

P.S. Don't hit me Breja. At least not the face.
avatar
Breja: What I really despise is sme ornate, barely readable shit like this.
avatar
Siegor: Those dice are gorgeous! Does anyone know where I could buy a set?
They're made by Q Workshop It's a polish store, but you can switch the language to english with the currency switch.
avatar
Breja: What really gets me is the "2-sided spell book die". You cant spin that. Or roll. Or do anything with it.
The book is basically a glorified coin flip. Grab a corner, chuck it into the air, and hope it is sturdy enough to survive impact. Personally, I'd rather use a quarter.
Why, wizards are known to be crazy :P

Btw, I remember a Spoony rant about silly dices XD
avatar
phaolo: Why, wizards are known to be crazy :P

Btw, I remember a Spoony rant about silly dices XD
You're right. It's possible I pretty much repeated what he said, without even realising it. I probably had that somewhere at the back of my head. Then again, I think it's something that pretty much everyone who ever DMed a game more than once or twice ran into that issue. I even had the misfortune of playing with a guy who had an oversized, metal d20 he insisted on using in crucial situations, and I'm convinced that thing was crafted by Satan himself with no purpose other than fucking up the game by making an unholly mess.
avatar
Breja: You're right. It's possible I pretty much repeated what he said, without even realising it. I probably had that somewhere at the back of my head. Then again, I think it's something that pretty much everyone who ever DMed a game more than once or twice ran into that issue. I even had the misfortune of playing with a guy who had an oversized, metal d20 he insisted on using in crucial situations, and I'm convinced that thing was crafted by Satan himself with no purpose other than fucking up the game by making an unholly mess.
I did bring my own dice to the table back in the day, just regular ones of course.
But on important rolls we players often used one particular d20 from the DMs set which was slightly inclined to land on the higher numbers.
That metal one does look nice and shiny though.