Posted August 05, 2022
my name is grompy catte: Got to disagree with you there. It's the fact that Vitek was the one counterclaiming that lent credence to his claim. If Scene was the town doctor there would have been very little reason for scum!Vitek to CC. And vice versa, if Vitek had for some reason claimed first and was counterclaimed by Scene I would have leaned towards believing Scene.
Catventurer: I apologize as I really did not make myself clear, which is entirely my fault. I only mean that we shouldn't be wasting time debating if Scene made a legitimate claim when he said that he was the Town Doctor. Dedo confirmed that Scene's role was Mafia JOAT. Since Dedo is the guy in charge of the game, we should be treating it as a fact that Scene is Mafia JOAT and not entertain any suggestions that Scene was the Town Doctor.
What is dodgy is that we have Frost soliciting advise from Scene AFTER Scene is lynched and confirms himself to be mafia-aligned. No amount of engaging in revisionism is going to change this.
Catventurer: Another thing with Frost, he is not stupid:
Post #532 Frost - razza is a she BTW and most likely Joe's daughter
Post #533 Pooka - if true, didn't know joe was a dad!
Post #534 Dedo - WTF JOE!!
Post #543 Catte - link to image of guy spitting out liquid in shock.
Post #547 Joe - our secret's out sweetheart :0 (to Razza)
Frost has been around for two games now, and he figures this out before people that have been playing with Joe a lot longer?
Ahh... sorry to ruin the joke, but it's not true. I've known Joe in real life for around 20 years and if he has a daughter he's kept it super secret, hence my spit-take. Anyway, I'm pretty confident (like 99.99% certain) Razza is not Joe's daughter. Frost is not the True Detective you consider them to be unfortunately.Post #532 Frost - razza is a she BTW and most likely Joe's daughter
Post #533 Pooka - if true, didn't know joe was a dad!
Post #534 Dedo - WTF JOE!!
Post #543 Catte - link to image of guy spitting out liquid in shock.
Post #547 Joe - our secret's out sweetheart :0 (to Razza)
Frost has been around for two games now, and he figures this out before people that have been playing with Joe a lot longer?