It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
ddickinson: Tempting, but I think I will pass. You could be Scum just trying to lure me away during the night. :-)
Okay


avatar
adaliabooks: I have suspicions of ddickinson, there are lots of little slips and odd things she's said that are starting to add up. It could easily just be newbie mistakes, but I think I would be at least willing to put some pressure on here and see what happens.
This is pretty much mirroring my own thoughts. I'm more interested in what will happen to Yog/replacement and CSPVG first, but dd is the next best thing.


avatar
HijacK: From what I talked to her on Steam, I gathered she's busy with the holidays.
And fixing the PCs of relatives.
avatar
adaliabooks: I have suspicions of ddickinson, there are lots of little slips and odd things she's said that are starting to add up. It could easily just be newbie mistakes, but I think I would be at least willing to put some pressure on here and see what happens.
avatar
dedoporno: This is pretty much mirroring my own thoughts. I'm more interested in what will happen to Yog/replacement and CSPVG first, but dd is the next best thing.
I've already said how I feel about that. I don't think it's worth the risk of lynching either of them tomorrow, especially if we didn't get a flip.

At least by day 3 we might have a few more reads / results and general info to figure out what's going on.
avatar
HypersomniacLive: If your goal is to not draw attention, for any of the possible reasons, I guess you've noticed that it's not working.
I did notice. It's strange how much attention my wording of things get. But I guess that is an important part of finding Scum, looking for slip ups. I have tried to explain why I used the wording I did, but I can understand people not being sure. That's why I said I will try to word things better, to avoid anyone thinking I have something to hide.
avatar
adaliabooks: I've already said how I feel about that. I don't think it's worth the risk of lynching either of them tomorrow, especially if we didn't get a flip.

At least by day 3 we might have a few more reads / results and general info to figure out what's going on.
I'm not talking about lynches at all. I meant how will they go through the night.
avatar
adaliabooks: I've already said how I feel about that. I don't think it's worth the risk of lynching either of them tomorrow, especially if we didn't get a flip.

At least by day 3 we might have a few more reads / results and general info to figure out what's going on.
avatar
dedoporno: I'm not talking about lynches at all. I meant how will they go through the night.
Sorry, I thought you meant lynching one of them as they might be scum.

Yeah, it will definitely be interesting to see who is the NK (or kills, I still haven't ruled out a second scum team, even with RWarehall being a SK). Whether it gives us any info is another matter...
avatar
adaliabooks: Whether it gives us any info is another matter...
True, but it's still something. We have to work with what we have... I really hope this won't turn into Groundhog Day and we won't end up Bill Murray-ing D1 all over again.
avatar
adaliabooks: Whether it gives us any info is another matter...
avatar
dedoporno: True, but it's still something. We have to work with what we have... I really hope this won't turn into Groundhog Day and we won't end up Bill Murray-ing D1 all over again.
I'd say that at least the NK will be guaranteed to be town, but that's not the case if we have two scum teams or more neutrals :S
avatar
adaliabooks: I'd say that at least the NK will be guaranteed to be town, but that's not the case if we have two scum teams or more neutrals :S
I tip my hat to flub for being able to create such chaos and still being confident he got this. I'm pretty sure we're in for a treat.
avatar
ddickinson: I did notice. It's strange how much attention my wording of things get. But I guess that is an important part of finding Scum, looking for slip ups. I have tried to explain why I used the wording I did, but I can understand people not being sure. That's why I said I will try to word things better, to avoid anyone thinking I have something to hide.
I guess you haven't started yet.
avatar
HijacK: Tell me, do you know why I asked you what was the last mafia game you followed?
Don't know. To underscore that you are more experienced than I? By the way, it was The Not Ending Soon War - (#24). So why did you ask?
avatar
HijacK: Tell me, do you know why I asked you what was the last mafia game you followed?
avatar
Lifthrasil: Don't know. To underscore that you are more experienced than I? By the way, it was The Not Ending Soon War - (#24). So why did you ask?
Do you also remember me saying this?

avatar
HijacK: As for why I think it's crap, you're doing the mistake many have done in my past games, and that's giving credit for trivial stuff that can easily be manipulated. Not too mention you superficially compare every player to a control variable type of play style, with few exceptions as JMich and CSPVG.
In that post, which I replied to, you talked about various scenarios that happened, yet in each case the scenario was either so trivial it was not worth mentioning, or you simply came up with reasons to incriminate people, reasons which I find dubious at best. If #24 is the last game you followed, you should by now have a decent idea of how the newest players since the last time you played are used to behave. It looks to me like a conflict of generations of players, more than actual scum hunting, because you're finding wrongdoings where I didn't.
avatar
HypersomniacLive: I guess you haven't started yet.
Well I thought I had started, but it seems I'm still wording things wrong. The part you put in bold wasn't a confession, I just meant that people keep thinking I have something to hide because I word things that can be seen suspicious. But it seems every time I try to explain things, it just make things worse.
avatar
HypersomniacLive: I guess you haven't started yet.
avatar
ddickinson: Well I thought I had started, but it seems I'm still wording things wrong. The part you put in bold wasn't a confession, I just meant that people keep thinking I have something to hide because I word things that can be seen suspicious. But it seems every time I try to explain things, it just make things worse.
You know, I'm starting to get the idea you are enjoying this.
avatar
HijacK: You know, I'm starting to get the idea you are enjoying this.
Therefore - scum! Because flub said so.
avatar
HypersomniacLive: I guess you haven't started yet.
avatar
ddickinson: Well I thought I had started, but it seems I'm still wording things wrong. The part you put in bold wasn't a confession, I just meant that people keep thinking I have something to hide because I word things that can be seen suspicious. But it seems every time I try to explain things, it just make things worse.
Welcome to a Mafia game..;)