I'm quite a fan of the ARPG genre and I have to say that this game is now among my favorites, if not my favorite.
I S:A you play as a demon that lives in a parallel world (the Shadow Realm). As the demon consumes the souls of its strongest enemies, it's allowed to manifest itself as those souls in the physical world.
This premise allows for two clever things.
First, instead of a single-character with a class, you play a menagerie of disparate characters (everything from a giant wasp to a wolf-man) that have unique skill sets. You have three at a time, but can switch them frequently. Using the right character for the situation and finding complimentary skills among your favorite characters is a key part of the fun.
Second, switching from the physical to the Shadow Realm freezes real-time, reveals different enemies, opens pathways and reveals runes and secrets, reinforcing the exploration aspect of the game and allowing for some clever mechanics on puzzles and boss fights.
This good premise is then combined with solid, fluid ARPG mechanics, simple puzzles that are a nice change of pace and encourage paying attention your surroundings, good music, superb voice-acting, good graphic design and a plot and characters that really bring out a wholesome feel of adventure (the cast of characters, particularly the demon, are quite endearing). Yes, outstandingly for ARPG's, there's an actual plot here, with true dialogue choices, a karma system and "choice-and-consequence". If any of this sounds appealing to you, try it - you won't regret it.