I have already finished this game 4 times, and tbh I will probably play this game few times more. While this game has its lacking (no game is 100% perfect) but this is the closest you can go. One of the best story telling you can come across in any game. The development of characters and the emotional attachment formed with me through out this game is an extraordinary experience. From a RPG fan point of view - PRO: Amazing graphics, character design, environment. Brilliant story and character development (it is recommended to get acquainted with the previous two games atleast if not the books) Side quests are absolutely worth doing and has their own story elements Great gameplay (while having few downsides) Amazing replay value CONS: You cannot make your own character, hence lacking in RPG sense a bit, but it makes up for it with everything else in my opinion. It is a must play in my book, one of the greatest game ever made.