This would be 5 stars, but I just can't do that with a few of the flaws. Flaws: -The formations should take more casualties before they turn back. -Formations pass through each other fairly often. I don't think too often one formation moved through another and then came back through again to their starting point. -General seems pointless. Perfection: -Art work is amazing. -Movement is great barring the two points above. -Makes me really believe I'm there. Side note: I wish they had the entire battlefield mapped and playable at one time and not require you to play section by section.
