Just finished this game and found it overall rewarding and enjoyable. I like dungeon crawlers and this is a deliberately old fashioned game, largely expanding on the experience of Legend of Grimrock, the original. However there were a few issues that stopped it from reaching the five star rating. Some of the puzzles are very tricky to even determine what is happening. There are often clues but if you miss these it can be annoying. You end up with a lot of clutter in your inventory and with no trading element you can carry as much as you can, or do what I did and dump a load of excess items. However it turned out I dumped an essential item and had to try and find it again - very frustrating. The last comment is that there is a lot of open play in the game, its far less linear than Legend of Grimrock, but this in itself causes some confusion. I got lost looking at one stage trying to figure what was next only to eventually realise I had to go back to go forward - maybe it was just me but seemed to be confusing. Now, I really enjoyed the game, good puzzles generally, not too hard and a good mix of characters, fighting and magic.
