Let me preface this by saying that Darkest Dungeon 1 has, from day one, been in my top three games of all time (the other two being Valheim and Crusader Kings 3). I, too, was gravely disappointed when they changed the formula. And even though the major flaw that, in my opinion, kept the first installment from perfection—the graphics—was greatly improved upon, I couldn’t imagine the game without the hamlet, where my party of psychiatric ward pati...—I mean, heroes—could return, giving me a sense of place and continuity. I refrained from getting DD2, hoping that one day they would release a third installment. And guess what? The latest game mode, Kingdoms, is exactly what I was dreaming of. And even though it may sound blasphemous to fans of the first installment, I’ll say it outright: DD2: Kingdoms is better than DD1. Now, with most readers gone, I will try to support my bold statement by comparing both games in the two most important aspects: the hamlet and the heroes. The hamlet is back—but this time, there isn’t just one, but dozens of them (called Inns). While in DD1, the order of upgrades was largely the same in every run, here you must decide which Inns will specialize in what: some will offer cheaper goods, others will have better medics, and some will let you train your heroes more effectively. You won’t be able to upgrade all of them, and some you will never get to visit again. It’s a fantastic feature that improves on the concept of the hamlet in every way. And now, for the biggest and best change: the heroes. In DD2: Kingdoms, you only have one of each type—which makes your connection to them much more personal. They are no longer disposable shells, replaced the moment they die by carbon copies. Instead, they feel like real people with quirks, relationships, and stories. Once they’re gone, they’re gone. You will miss them, but they will not be forgotten nor replaced. Alright, I’m reaching the character limit, so I’ll end with this: Get the game.
Don’t listen to the critics. Sure, it’s not X-COM in terms of gameplay or story, but it’s still an excellent game in its own right. The tactical combat feels more like solving a puzzle than engaging in the dynamic battlefield scenarios typical of the X-COM franchise. Yet, it’s deeply satisfying to figure it out and pull off feats like taking down 8+ opponents in a single turn—something that initially seemed impossible. Coupled with a solid story and fantastic character customization mechanics, Hard West 2 gave me everything I hoped for and then some.
Most points about the sequel have already been made: I also find the story somewhat lacking, and the quality of the puzzles doesn't quite match that of the first installment. However, don't let these nuances discourage you from diving into this fantastic universe, especially if you enjoyed the first game. It remains a remarkable title in its own right, and if I hadn't experienced LN1, I would probably have given it 5 stars. Consider me spoiled! :P
I played a lot of card games and most of them seem completely detached from the story, where your only issue is optimizing your hand. Here, on the other hand, the cards are nicely interwined with the story (simple but well written), so you know why you have them and can picture what they actually do. The game mechanics may not be overly complicated but still manages to offer certain depth and drew me in to the point where I wanted to play one more encounter. I am surprised I got it for free. If I'd had a chance to try it beforehand, I would have been willing to pay for it.
I don't like writing reviews but I would feel bad if I did not support the authors after such an incredible experience. I wish the game had never ended. If you like books, adventure games and complex characters, just get it.
The last time I had so much fun playing FPS was about 20 years ago with Duke Nukem 3D. Shadow Warrior 2 boast a similarly obnoxious macho-type protagonist, this one, however, is much more vocal. As a teenager I'd have adored the guy – today, 20 years later he sounded cheesy... until Kamiko appeared and turned everything upside down (easy, no spoilers ahead). The dynamics between the two is fantastic. Body language, dialogues, everything. I got invested in the story thanks to them. I read every journal entry because I want to know more about the context they are in. I rush through the game just to hear them talk. As for the gameplay, everything has been said already. Some FPSs work, others not. This one not only does, but it has the best FPS sword combat ever! It is so good that I stopped using guns and never came back. Love the game.
