All the negative reviews here have very good points and I encourage you to check them out to make up your mind, but I just want you to know that everything about this game clicks for me. Yeah doors are buggier, dogs keep chasing their tails, rooms are bigger than in the first meaning some levels are apparently impossible without lots of guns. But I'm hooked. I didn't get hooked on the original, but this one, I don't know why, got me. Hard. Bought it day one, played it through and through and I'll keep going for a long while. I love everything about it, 5 stars, no regret. But yeah if you were more invested in the first than I was, you might want to do a bit of research.