Good: gunplay, music, fun challenges
Meh: you enter an arena like place, all doors close, kill all mobs then doors open. Rinse and repeat
Bad: no hard save, no quicksave, only checkpoint
Pirate theme, a lot water: Navigation skill useful.
Music is still very good.
Lot of backtracking, high level creatures only available late in game.
Difficulty: so unfair it's not fun, couldn't finish it...