The game has it's strengthes. - The overall story is well made - The power progression system is good. - The alchemy system, finding recipes, learning about herbs and how to gather them is appealing. - Some tactical chocies made in the game can be interesting and have consequences. However, the game has weaknesses as well. - Moral choices were not well made since everyone is evil. In order for moral choices to exist there needs to be good and evil not just evil and very evil. - I personally disliked the main character Geralt. He looked to me like a h*rny and greedy individual. - The combat system is boring. Very dungeon crawler like with point and click combat. - Quests were a mess and lacked direction through text not just quest tracking. I played the game for 6 hours then stopped. I would continue playing if the combat system was more entertaining and engaging. So if you like ARPG with point and click combat and everyone in the story being evil this maybe a 5 star game for you but if you like a more engaging combat system and a flavor of good and evil this game may feel underwhelming for you.