I never played the old fps dungeon crawlers and I enjoy LoG immensely, which proves that this is not just a nostalgia trip. The puzzles are fun to figure out and the game has tons of oh sh*t moments caused by the clever traps. The atmosphere is just top notch. I started a new game after initial playthrough and keep finding new secrets, so the game has some replay value. There is room for improvement in combat and skills, which are quite simple. Also I've already started to fantasize about a sequel that could have friendly npcs, shops, quests, underground villages and new types of puzzles, monsters, dungeons, spell effects and more. A clear game of the year contender. Play it.