top 5 all time for my favorite games... thats not to say that it's perfect because it's not. it feels like a lot was cut in order to release when it did... but the game is great and I hope for an even better sequel.
I really like the quests, the characters, the music, the world itself. Disappointed in the Enemy/NPC/Polic AI but it's not a deal breaker for me. You will also need to deal with bugs and graphical issues but again not a deal breaker for me. I'm playing on a beefy pc btw. CDPR definitely needs to work on enemy/npc/police ai, and also allow us to remap all keys/actions like dodge... how was that not an issue during internal testing? I'm always dodging out of cover accidentally whjen I'm crouched. I also think they need to work on the crafting a bit because the requirements can be a lot.. both materials for crafting and the perks/skills required.